{"ontologies":{"AGLS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.agls.gov.au/agls/terms"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://agls.gov.au/schemas/rdfs/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"AGLS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.agls.gov.au/agls/terms/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The AGLS Metadata Terms Namespace provides URIs for the AGLS Metadata Terms Vocabulary in the context of AGLS Metadata Standard, a set of metadata properties and associated usage guidelines to improve the visibility, manageability and interoperability of online information and services. Vocabulary terms are declared using RDF Schema language to support RDF applications. It will be updated according to AGLS Working Group decisions.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"AGLS Metadata Terms","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Archives of Australia (NAA)\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/091f1630-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/091f1630-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.naa.gov.au/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AGLS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2010-06-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=AGLS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AGLS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AGLS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AGLS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=AGLS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AGLS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AGLS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AGLS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.agls.gov.au/agls/terms","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.agls.gov.au/agls/terms"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.agls.gov.au/agls/1.2/\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AGLS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.agls.gov.au/agls/1.2/\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Archives of Australia (NAA)\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/091f1630-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/091f1630-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.naa.gov.au/\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AGLS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2010-06-30"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":310},"AMV":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/amv"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/amv/1.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"AMV","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/amv#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Metadata vocabularies are used in various domains of study. It provides an in-depth description of the resources. In this work, we develop Algorithm Metadata Vocabulary (AMV), a vocabulary for capturing and storing the metadata about the algorithms (a procedure or a set of rules that is followed step-by-step to solve a problem, especially by a computer). The snag faced by the researchers in the current time is the failure of getting relevant results when searching for algorithms in any search engine. AMV is represented as a semantic model and produced OWL file, which can be directly used by anyone interested to create and publish algorithm metadata as a knowledge graph, or to provide metadata service through SPARQL endpoint. To design the vocabulary, we propose a well-defined methodology, which considers real issues faced by the algorithm users and the practitioners. The evaluation shows a promising result.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"AMV:Algorithm Metadata Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Indian Statistical Institute Bangalore Centre\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f950d830-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f950d830-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.isibang.ac.in/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"amv","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AMV/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2023-02-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=AMV&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AMV/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AMV/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AMV/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=AMV&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AMV/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AMV/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AMV","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/amv","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/amv"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[https://schema.org/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://schema.org/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"http://www.wikidata.org/entity/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\"]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.54,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[https://w3id.org/mod, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.54,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[https://schema.org/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://schema.org/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AMV/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\"]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"http://www.wikidata.org/entity/","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.54,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3059-8202\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3059-8202\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Biswanath Dutta\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ad507d20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ad507d20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jyotima Patel\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/af329d00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/af329d00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AMV/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"V1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[\"Example competency questions. \\nCQ1: What characteristics or properties are common across all algorithms?\\nCQ2: List all algorithms that compute the solution to problem X along with their types and input. \\nCQ3: Retrieve an algorithm that solves problem X with its details like best case space complexity, best case time complexity, and the problems related to it. \\nCQ4: Retrieve all the algorithms X which are expressed in the form of a flowchart.\\nCQ5: Which Sorting algorithms are derived from the already existing sorting algorithms?\"]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":265.54,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1577},"APCO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.org/cm/onto/apco"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"APCO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://purl.org/cm/onto/apco#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"APCO is an ontology that allows the description of public procurement terms","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Government\",\"Services\"]","dct:title":"African Public Contract Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/APCO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2022-08-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=APCO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/APCO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/APCO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2022-09-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/APCO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=APCO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fr]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/APCO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/APCO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/APCO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.org/cm/onto/apco","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://purl.org/cm/onto/apco"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://contsem.unizar.es/def/sector-publico/pproc, http://data.ign.fr/def/geofla, http://purl.org/procurement/public-contracts, https://dbpedia.org/ontology/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://contsem.unizar.es/def/sector-publico/pproc, http://data.ign.fr/def/geofla, http://purl.org/procurement/public-contracts, https://dbpedia.org/ontology/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/APCO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-1562-6922\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-1562-6922\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ghislain Atemezing\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d3de2660-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d3de2660-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jules Quentin Kouamo\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/dfe7b560-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/dfe7b560-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Etienne Kouakam\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fd139b40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fd139b40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/APCO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":236.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":5805},"ACRT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://privatealpha.com/ontology/certification/1#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ACRT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://privatealpha.com/ontology/certification/1#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://creativecommons.org/ns","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This document specifies a vocabulary for asserting the existence of official endorsements or certifications of agents, such as people and organizations.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Quality\"]","dct:title":"Agent Certification Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"acrt","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACRT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2014-01-23T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ACRT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This document specifies a vocabulary for asserting the existence of official endorsements or certifications of <em xmlns=\\\"http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml\\\" xmlns:acrt=\\\"http://privatealpha.com/ontology/certification/1#\\\" xmlns:bibo=\\\"http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/\\\" xmlns:dct=\\\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\\\" xmlns:foaf=\\\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\\\" xmlns:owl=\\\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#\\\" xmlns:rdf=\\\"http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#\\\" xmlns:rdfs=\\\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\\\" xmlns:skos=\\\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#\\\" xmlns:vann=\\\"http://purl.org/vocab/vann/\\\" xmlns:xsd=\\\"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#\\\">agents<\\/em>, such as people and organizations.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACRT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACRT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACRT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ACRT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACRT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACRT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACRT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://privatealpha.com/ontology/certification/1#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://privatealpha.com/ontology/certification/1#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.13,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.13,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACRT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.13,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dorian Taylor\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f10f5c70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f10f5c70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACRT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2014-01-23"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":239.13,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1099},"AO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/ao/core#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"AO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/ontology/ao/core#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Provides basic concepts and properties for describing specific association statements to something, e.g. an occasion, a genre or a mood ...","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Support\"]","dct:title":"Association Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2010-09-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=AO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=AO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/ao/core#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/ao/core#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/ontology/similarity/, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/, http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/, http://purl.org/stuff/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/ontology/similarity/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/ontology/similarity/\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/event.owl\",\"http://purl.org/stuff/rev#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":20.75,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/ontology/similarity/, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/, http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/, http://purl.org/stuff/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/ontology/similarity/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/ontology/similarity/\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/event.owl\",\"http://purl.org/stuff/rev#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":60.75,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Toby Inkster\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c38caec0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c38caec0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bob Ferris\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f7452f80-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f7452f80-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.4"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":255.75,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1224},"ACL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/auth/acl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.w3.org/wiki/WebAccessControl","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ACL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/ns/auth/acl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Defines the element of Authorization and its essential properties,     and also some classes of access such as read and write.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"API\"]","dct:title":"Basic Access Control ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-12-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ACL&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Defines the element of Authorization and its essential properties,\\r\\n    and also some classes of access such as read and write.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ACL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/auth/acl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/auth/acl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2006/gen/ont, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2006/gen/ont, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"W3C\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"W3C\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.w3.org/data#W3C\"}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Henry Story\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/01b86d10-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/01b86d10-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ACL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2012-12-18"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/W3C"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":437},"CITEDCAT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/citedcat-ap"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://ec-jrc.github.io/datacite-to-dcat-ap/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CITEDCAT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/citedcat-ap/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"CiteDCAT-AP is an extension of the DCAT application profile for data portals in Europe (DCAT-AP) for describing resources documented by using the DataCite metadata schema - the de facto standard for data citation, and used across scientific disciplines. Its basic use case is to make research data searchable on general data portals, thereby bridging the gap between scientific and public sector information. For this purpose, CiteDCAT-AP provides an RDF vocabulary and the corresponding RDF syntax binding for the metadata elements defined in DataCite.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Catalogs\",\"Methods\"]","dct:title":"CiteDCAT-AP Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"The European Commission\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c63a4da0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c63a4da0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/European_Commission\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"citedcat","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CITEDCAT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"CiteDCAT-AP is an extension of the DCAT application profile for data portals in Europe (DCAT-AP) for describing resources documented by using the DataCite metadata schema - the de facto standard for data citation, and used across scientific disciplines. Its basic use case is to make research data searchable on general data portals, thereby bridging the gap between scientific and public sector information. For this purpose, CiteDCAT-AP provides an RDF vocabulary and the corresponding RDF syntax binding for the metadata elements defined in DataCite.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2021-03-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CITEDCAT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"CiteDCAT-AP is an extension of the DCAT application profile for data portals in Europe (DCAT-AP) for describing resources documented by using the DataCite metadata schema - the de facto standard for data citation, and used across scientific disciplines. Its basic use case is to make research data searchable on general data portals, thereby bridging the gap between scientific and public sector information. For this purpose, CiteDCAT-AP provides an RDF vocabulary and the corresponding RDF syntax binding for the metadata elements defined in DataCite.\",\"First version of the CiteDCAT-AP RDF Vocabulary, including only the terms defined in the CiteDCAT-AP namespace.\",\"This version of CiteDCAT-AP is aligned with the following specifications: DCAT 2, DCAT-AP 2.0.1, GeoDCAT-AP 2.0.0, StatDCAT-AP 1.0.1, DataCite 4.4.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CITEDCAT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CITEDCAT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2021-03-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CITEDCAT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CITEDCAT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CITEDCAT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CITEDCAT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CITEDCAT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/citedcat-ap","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/citedcat-ap"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2007/05/powder-s]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.13,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/adms, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns, http://purl.org/vocommons/voaf]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.13,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2007/05/powder-s]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CITEDCAT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.13,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andrea Perego\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cf384fd0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cf384fd0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lorenzino Vaccari\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/daaa7d00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/daaa7d00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Timothy Austin\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e10a88d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e10a88d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Chrisa Tsinaraki\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f8590400-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f8590400-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Anders Friis-Christensen\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fb755570-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fb755570-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CITEDCAT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Version 1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"https://schema.datacite.org/","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":258.13,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1469},"CON":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2000/10/swap/pim/contact"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CON","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/2000/10/swap/pim/contact#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Utility concepts for everyday life","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"People\"]","dct:title":"Contact","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"W3C\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"W3C\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.w3.org/data#W3C\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CON/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2011-02-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CON&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CON/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CON/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CON/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CON&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fr]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CON/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CON/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CON","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2000/10/swap/pim/contact","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2000/10/swap/pim/contact"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CON/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tim Berners-Lee\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fc3dd530-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fc3dd530-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CON/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.18"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":238.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":388},"CRO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rhizomik.net/ontologies/copyrightonto.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://rhizomik.net/html/ontologies/copyrightonto/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CRO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rhizomik.net/ontologies/copyrightonto.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Copyright Ontology is a contribution geared towards the development of copyright-aware Digital Rights Management (DRM) systems.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Multimedia\"]","dct:title":"Copyright Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"cro","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CRO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2019-09-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CRO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CRO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CRO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CRO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CRO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CRO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CRO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CRO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rhizomik.net/ontologies/copyrightonto.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rhizomik.net/ontologies/copyrightonto.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[https://raw.githubusercontent.com/schemaorg/schemaorg/master/data/releases/3.9/, https://rhizomik.net/ontologies/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.33,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[https://raw.githubusercontent.com/schemaorg/schemaorg/master/data/releases/3.9/, https://rhizomik.net/ontologies/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CRO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.33,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Roberto García\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e86fd620-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e86fd620-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CRO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2019.0902"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.33,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":747},"CO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/co/core#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/ontology/co/core#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Counter Ontology specification provides basic concepts and properties for describing a general counter concept and some important sub counters","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Methods\"]","dct:title":"Counter Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2010-09-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/co/core#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/co/core#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/, http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/event.owl, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/event.owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/, http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/event.owl, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/event.owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mats Skillingstad\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e4c6d200-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e4c6d200-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yves Raimond\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e7506200-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e7506200-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bob Ferris\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f7452f80-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f7452f80-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.81"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.75,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1259},"CEM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/CEMontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":3.0,"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[\"https://w3id.org/CEMontology/\",\"info:doi:10.13140/RG.2.2.18252.90243\"]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://crimeanalytics.it/cem-reference/cem.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":80,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CEM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/CEMontology/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Crime Event Model is an ontology for the representation of crime events extracted from local newspapers. It could be employed for Crime Analysis purposes: extracting crime information from newspapers and enriching them with proper machine-readable semantics is a critical task to help law enforcement agencies at preventing crime, supporting criminal investigations and evaluating the action of law enforcement agencies themselves. The model is based on the fundamental 5W1H journalistic questions, that are Who?, What?, When?, Where?, Why? and How?. Another important requirement was the attempt to exploit existing knowledge graphs and ontologies such as the Simple Event Model (SEM) Ontology and the Schema.org data model for interoperability and interconnection.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Methods\",\"Events\"]","dct:title":"Crime Event Model (CEM)","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"University of Modena and Reggio Emilia\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e3978bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e3978bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.unimore.it/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"cem","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CEM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2022-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CEM&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The Crime Event Model is an ontology for the representation of crime events extracted from local newspapers. It could be employed for Crime Analysis purposes: extracting crime information from newspapers and enriching them with proper machine-readable semantics is a critical task to help law enforcement agencies at preventing crime, supporting criminal investigations and evaluating the action of law enforcement agencies themselves. The model is based on the fundamental 5W1H journalistic questions, that are Who?, What?, When?, Where?, Why? and How?. Another important requirement was the attempt to exploit existing knowledge graphs and ontologies such as the Simple Event Model (SEM) Ontology and the Schema.org data model for interoperability and interconnection.\",\"-Version 1.1: Insertion of ontology descriptors to be inserted in Linked Open Vocabulary-Version 1: creation\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CEM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CEM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2022-10-26T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CEM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CEM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CEM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CEM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CEM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":79.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/CEMontology","dct:identifier":"[\"https://w3id.org/CEMontology/\",\"info:doi:10.13140/RG.2.2.18252.90243\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/CEMontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.33,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CEM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":43.33,"normalizedScore":39,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Federica Rollo\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b8dddf60-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b8dddf60-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Laura Po\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fba9a2f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fba9a2f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CEM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":259.33,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1396},"DSD":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/dsd"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DSD","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/dsd#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"To ensure comparability between schemas from different data models, the Description of a Data Source (DSD) vocabulary has been developed.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Catalogs\",\"API\"]","dct:title":"Description of a Data Source","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institute for Application-oriented Knowledge Processing, Johannes Kepler University Linz\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cc6e4ae0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cc6e4ae0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.jku.at/faw\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DSD/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2023-03-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=DSD&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DSD/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DSD/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DSD/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=DSD&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DSD/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DSD/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DSD","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/dsd","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/dsd"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://schema.org/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/doi:, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns#status:]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.5,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DSD/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.5,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5313-0368\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5313-0368\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Lisa Ehrlinger\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/acfe0f30-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/acfe0f30-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DSD/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v4.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":238.5,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1221},"DOCSO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/dso"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DOCSO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/ontology/dso#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A micro-ontology that defines a set of typical document-related services such as provided by libraries, museums and archives.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Services\"]","dct:title":"Document Service Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dso","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DOCSO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2013-12-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=DOCSO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DOCSO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DOCSO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2013-12-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DOCSO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=DOCSO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DOCSO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DOCSO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DOCSO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":65.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/dso","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/dso"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/service\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns, http://creativecommons.org/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.33,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DOCSO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/service\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.33,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DOCSO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0;65"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.33,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1346},"EURIO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.europa.eu/s66#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EURIO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://data.europa.eu/s66#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The EUropean Research Information Ontology (EURIO) conceptualises, formally encodes and makes available in an open, structured and machine-readable format data about resarch projects funded by the EU's framework programmes for research and innovation.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\",\"Academy\"]","dct:title":"EURIO: EUropean Research Information Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Publications Office of the European Commission\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/61a21d90-b801-013e-3e87-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/61a21d90-b801-013e-3e87-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/corporate-body/PUBL\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EURIO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-12-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2021-08-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=EURIO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EURIO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EURIO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2025-05-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EURIO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=EURIO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EURIO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EURIO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EURIO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.europa.eu/s66#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.europa.eu/s66#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/cerif/frapo/\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#\",\"http://schema.org/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://data.europa.eu/m8g/\",\"https://w3id.org/dingo/\",\"http://purl.org/spar/fabio\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/locn\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/adms, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.33,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EURIO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/cerif/frapo/\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#\",\"http://schema.org/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://data.europa.eu/m8g/\",\"https://w3id.org/dingo/\",\"http://purl.org/spar/fabio\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/locn\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.33,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Publications Office of the European Commission\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/61a21d90-b801-013e-3e87-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/61a21d90-b801-013e-3e87-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/corporate-body/PUBL\"}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cognizone\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/573ee470-b801-013e-3e87-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/573ee470-b801-013e-3e87-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://opencorporates.com/companies/be/0634615174\"}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EURIO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2.5.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.33,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":317},"IADOPT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/iadopt/ont"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/iadopt/ont/0.9.1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IADOPT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/iadopt/ont/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The I-ADOPT Framework ontology","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Biology\",\"Environment\"]","dct:title":"I-ADOPT Framework ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IADOPT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#UpperLevelOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[\"Variable\",\"Entity\",\"Property\"]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The I-ADOPT Framework ontology provides machine-readable variable descriptions in which the components are mapped to FAIR vocabulary terms.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2021-10-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=IADOPT&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IADOPT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IADOPT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IADOPT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=IADOPT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-3/eng","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IADOPT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IADOPT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IADOPT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/iadopt/ont","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/iadopt/ont"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level present. (https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Schema)","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Schema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat, http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.44,"normalizedScore":17,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IADOPT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Schema","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2195-3997\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2195-3997\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Barbara Magagna\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ad737220-d588-013d-b4bc-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ad737220-d588-013d-b4bc-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-6559-4178\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-6559-4178\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gwenaëlle Moncoiffé\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9bd82ef0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9bd82ef0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5040-4626\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5040-4626\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alison Pamment\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a93dd2c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a93dd2c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0870-3192\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0870-3192\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Anusuriya Devaraju\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/dfa6b8d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/dfa6b8d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-6612-3439\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-6612-3439\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maria Stoica\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e1c94060-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e1c94060-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-0964-4457\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-0964-4457\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sirko Schindler\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/084ddd60-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/084ddd60-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-6875-5360\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-6875-5360\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"John Graybeal\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc537bc0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc537bc0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Robert Huber\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cbc3e8e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cbc3e8e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-3884-3420\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-3884-3420\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Simon J D Cox\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d6071460-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d6071460-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IADOPT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.9.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#DescriptionLogics","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[\"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#Protege\"]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"https://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod/index.html#MethOntology"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":15.0,"normalizedScore":39,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/ODP"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":248.44,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1475},"DTX_SRTI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/def/transporte/dtx_srti"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DTX_SRTI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/def/transporte/dtx_srti#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An RDF/OWL vocabulary to represent SRTI DATEX II profile (according the Commission  Delegated Regulation (EU) No 886/2013) within the European  LOD-RoadTran18 action  \"Supporting the cross-border use of Road Traffic Data with Linked Open Data based on DATEX II (LOD-RoadTran18)\" (Agreement No: INEA/CEF/ICT/A2018/1803421, Action No: 2018-EU-IA-0088). The  vocabulary is used for mapping between DATEX II and LOD formats.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Transport\"]","dct:title":"LOD SRTI DATEX II","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"IRTIC - (Instituto de Robótica y Tecnologías de la Información y la Comunicación)\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cf0cf130-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cf0cf130-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://irtic.uv.es/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"dtx_srti","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DTX_SRTI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2022-03-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=DTX_SRTI&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DTX_SRTI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DTX_SRTI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DTX_SRTI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=DTX_SRTI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/es]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DTX_SRTI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DTX_SRTI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DTX_SRTI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/def/transporte/dtx_srti","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/def/transporte/dtx_srti"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://www.opengis.net/ont/, http://www.w3.org/2006/time#2016, https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/ramon/ontologies/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2003/01/geo/wgs84_pos, http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/def/transporte/dtx_srti/administrativeUnit#, http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/def/transporte/dtx_srti/roads#, https://datos.ign.es/def/geo_core#, http://datex2.eu/schema/3/Common/3_1#, http://www.omg.org/spec/LCC/Countries/CountryRepresentation#, http://www.omg.org/spec/LCC/Countries/CountryRepresentationi#, http://data.europa.eu/nuts/code/, https://www.omg.org/spec/LCC/Languages/LanguageRepresentation/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema, http://qudt.org/schema/qudt]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://www.w3.org/2006/time, https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/ramon/ontologies/geographic.rdf#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2003/01/geo/wgs84_pos\",\"http://www.opengis.net/ont/geosparql\",\"http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://www.w3.org/2006/time\",\"http://qudt.org/schema/qudt#\",\"http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/def/transporte/dtx_srti/administrativeUnit#\",\"http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/def/transporte/dtx_srti/roads#\",\"http://www.omg.org/spec/LCC/Countries/CountryRepresentation#\",\"http://www.omg.org/spec/LCC/Countries/CountryRepresentationi#\",\"http://data.europa.eu/nuts/code/\",\"https://www.omg.org/spec/LCC/Languages/LanguageRepresentation/\",\"https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/ramon/ontologies/geographic.rdf#\"]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2003/01/geo/wgs84_pos\",\"http://www.opengis.net/ont/geosparql\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2006/time\",\"http://qudt.org/schema/qudt#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":20.44,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://www.opengis.net/ont/, http://www.w3.org/2006/time#2016, https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/ramon/ontologies/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2003/01/geo/wgs84_pos, http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/def/transporte/dtx_srti/administrativeUnit#, http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/def/transporte/dtx_srti/roads#, https://datos.ign.es/def/geo_core#, http://datex2.eu/schema/3/Common/3_1#, http://www.omg.org/spec/LCC/Countries/CountryRepresentation#, http://www.omg.org/spec/LCC/Countries/CountryRepresentationi#, http://data.europa.eu/nuts/code/, https://www.omg.org/spec/LCC/Languages/LanguageRepresentation/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema, http://qudt.org/schema/qudt]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DTX_SRTI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2003/01/geo/wgs84_pos\",\"http://www.opengis.net/ont/geosparql\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2006/time\",\"http://qudt.org/schema/qudt#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2003/01/geo/wgs84_pos\",\"http://www.opengis.net/ont/geosparql\",\"http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://www.w3.org/2006/time\",\"http://qudt.org/schema/qudt#\",\"http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/def/transporte/dtx_srti/administrativeUnit#\",\"http://cef.uv.es/lodroadtran18/def/transporte/dtx_srti/roads#\",\"http://www.omg.org/spec/LCC/Countries/CountryRepresentation#\",\"http://www.omg.org/spec/LCC/Countries/CountryRepresentationi#\",\"http://data.europa.eu/nuts/code/\",\"https://www.omg.org/spec/LCC/Languages/LanguageRepresentation/\",\"https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/ramon/ontologies/geographic.rdf#\"]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://www.w3.org/2006/time, https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/ramon/ontologies/geographic.rdf#]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":60.44,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Julian Gutierrez Moret\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fae23910-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fae23910-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"J. Javier Samper Zapater\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fb454480-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fb454480-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DTX_SRTI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":266.44,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":772},"LH":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/legalhtml/ov"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/legalhtml/ov-1.0.0-rc.1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"LH","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/legalhtml/ov#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An ontology for metadata about legal texts represented using the LegalHTML format","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"LegalHTML Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"lh","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LH/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2023-05-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=LH&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LH/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LH/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LH/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=LH&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LH/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LH/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LH","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":74.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/legalhtml/ov","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/legalhtml/ov"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://data.europa.eu/eli/ontology]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://data.europa.eu/eli/ontology, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://data.europa.eu/eli/ontology\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.33,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://data.europa.eu/eli/ontology]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://data.europa.eu/eli/ontology, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LH/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://data.europa.eu/eli/ontology\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://joinup.ec.europa.eu/software/page/eupl","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.33,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://joinup.ec.europa.eu/software/page/eupl"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Armando Stellato\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a5bbc490-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a5bbc490-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Manuel Fiorelli\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/10953180-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/10953180-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LH/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2023-05-08"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":268.33,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1428},"MEXALGO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://mex.aksw.org/mex-algo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MEXALGO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://mex.aksw.org/mex-algo#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"MEX is an RDF vocabulary designed to facilitate interoperability between published machine learning experiments results on the Web. The mex-algo layer represents the algorithm information existing into a basic machine learning experiment.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Methods\"]","dct:title":"MEX Algorithm Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"AKSW\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"AKSW Research Group - Leipzig University\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fe384af0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fe384af0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://data.semanticweb.org/organization/universitaet-leipzig-institut-fuer-informatik-aksw\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXALGO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2014-04-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MEXALGO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"MEX is an RDF vocabulary designed to facilitate interoperability between published machine learning experiments results on the Web. The mex-algo layer represents the algorithm information existing into a basic machine learning experiment.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXALGO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXALGO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2014-04-05T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXALGO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MEXALGO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/pt]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXALGO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXALGO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXALGO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://mex.aksw.org/mex-algo","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://mex.aksw.org/mex-algo"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://usefulinc.com/ns/doap#, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://usefulinc.com/ns/doap#\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://usefulinc.com/ns/doap#, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXALGO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://usefulinc.com/ns/doap#\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Diego Esteves\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e91c8310-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e91c8310-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sebastian Hellmann\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/7c874c40-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/7c874c40-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Julio Cesar Duarte\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9f3d0680-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9f3d0680-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Diego Moussallem\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/aa2345b0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/aa2345b0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jens Lehmann\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b6a2f790-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b6a2f790-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ricardo Usbeck\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d05c5bc0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d05c5bc0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Ackermann\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/eff74ed0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/eff74ed0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maria Claudia Cavalcanti Reis\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0a117520-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0a117520-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXALGO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":260.75,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":807},"MEXPERF":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://mex.aksw.org/mex-perf"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MEXPERF","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://mex.aksw.org/mex-perf#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"MEX is an RDF vocabulary designed to facilitate interoperability between published machine learning experiments results on the Web. The mex-perf layer is the 3rd level of the MEX for representing the machine learning algorithm's performances.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Methods\"]","dct:title":"MEX Performance Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"AKSW\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"AKSW Research Group - Leipzig University\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fe384af0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fe384af0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://data.semanticweb.org/organization/universitaet-leipzig-institut-fuer-informatik-aksw\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXPERF/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2016-05-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MEXPERF&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXPERF/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXPERF/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXPERF/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MEXPERF&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/pt]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXPERF/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXPERF/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXPERF","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://mex.aksw.org/mex-perf","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://mex.aksw.org/mex-perf"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://usefulinc.com/ns/doap#, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://usefulinc.com/ns/doap#, http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXPERF/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Diego Esteves\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e91c8310-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e91c8310-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sebastian Hellmann\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/7c874c40-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/7c874c40-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Julio Cesar Duarte\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9f3d0680-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9f3d0680-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Diego Moussallem\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/aa2345b0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/aa2345b0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jens Lehmann\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b6a2f790-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b6a2f790-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":null,\"agentType\":null,\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":null,\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c5c7eb50-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c5c7eb50-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Markus Ackermann\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/eff74ed0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/eff74ed0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maria Claudia Cavalcanti Reis\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0a117520-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0a117520-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MEXPERF/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":260.75,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":713},"MOD":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/mod/2.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MOD","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This specification describes MOD, a metadata vocabulary to describe and publish ontologies","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"MOD: Metadata for Ontology Description and publication","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"Indian Statistical Institute\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Indian Statistical Institute\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9cde7b70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9cde7b70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.isibang.ac.in/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MOD/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2021-12-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MOD&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MOD/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MOD/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MOD/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MOD&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MOD/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MOD/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MOD","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.isibang.ac.in/ns/mod"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MOD/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3059-8202\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3059-8202\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Biswanath Dutta\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ad507d20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ad507d20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Durgesh Nandini\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/057229b0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/057229b0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MOD/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":234.0,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1915},"MSR":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.telegraphis.net/ontology/measurement/measurement#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MSR","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.telegraphis.net/ontology/measurement/measurement#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Measurement Ontology is an ontology in which measurements may be rendered","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Methods\"]","dct:title":"Measurement Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MSR/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2009-06-06T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MSR&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MSR/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MSR/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MSR/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MSR&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MSR/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MSR/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MSR","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.telegraphis.net/ontology/measurement/measurement#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.telegraphis.net/ontology/measurement/measurement#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://vocab.deri.ie/scovo\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.75,"normalizedScore":17,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MSR/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://vocab.deri.ie/scovo\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.75,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ian Jacobi\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/dcfc48d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/dcfc48d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MSR/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2009-06-06"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":231.75,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1427},"MODSCI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/skgo/modsci#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/skgo/modsci/1.1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MODSCI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/skgo/modsci#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"ModSci is a reference ontology for modelling different types of modern sciences and related entities, such as scientific discoveries, renowned scientists, instruments, phenomena ... etc.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Society\",\"Academy\"]","dct:title":"ModSci, Modern Science Ontology.","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"modsci","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MODSCI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2022-12-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MODSCI&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MODSCI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MODSCI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2022-12-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MODSCI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MODSCI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MODSCI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MODSCI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MODSCI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/skgo/modsci#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/skgo/modsci#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://sweetontology.net/phen/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://sweetontology.net/phen/\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.5,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://sweetontology.net/phen/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MODSCI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://sweetontology.net/phen/\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.5,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Said Fathalla\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bd35ec40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bd35ec40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MODSCI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":261.5,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1438},"CBS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://betalinkeddata.cbs.nl/def/cbs"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CBS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://betalinkeddata.cbs.nl/def/cbs#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Vocabulary for datasets from the Netherlands' National Statistics Office","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Geography\",\"Government\"]","dct:title":"Netherlands' National Statistics Office (CBS) ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Centraal Bureau voor de Statistiek\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a46039c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a46039c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://standaarden.overheid.nl/owms/terms/Centraal_Bureau_voor_de_Statistiek\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"cbs","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CBS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2018-05-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CBS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CBS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CBS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2018-05-02T01:00:00.000+01:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CBS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CBS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/nl","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CBS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CBS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CBS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://betalinkeddata.cbs.nl/def/cbs","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://betalinkeddata.cbs.nl/def/cbs"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/linked-data/cube, http://www.opengis.net/ont/geosparql]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.opengis.net/ont/geosparql\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://vocab.deri.ie/void, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.33,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/linked-data/cube, http://www.opengis.net/ont/geosparql]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CBS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.opengis.net/ont/geosparql\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.33,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Kadaster Data Platform\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9c648590-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9c648590-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://localhost:3030/lov/dataplatform@kadaster.nl\"}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Erwin Folmer\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ac64b080-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ac64b080-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"erwin.folmer@kadaster.nl\",\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CBS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2018-05-02"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":246.33,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6302},"OFO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ofo#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OFO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/ofo#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The aim of the Occupant Feedback Ontology is to semantically describe passive and active occupant feedback and to enable integration of this feedback with linked building data.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"IoT\",\"Services\"]","dct:title":"Occupant Feedback Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"ofo","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2022-02-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=OFO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=OFO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":65.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ofo#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ofo#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, https://www.schema.org/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.33,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.33,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-8809-3277\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-8809-3277\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alex Donkers\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a8781d70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a8781d70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bauke de Vries\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a4296a70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a4296a70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3124-6604\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3124-6604\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dujuan Yang\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b99d54d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b99d54d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":234.33,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1233},"ONTOUML":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ontouml"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/ontouml/vocabulary/v1.1.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://w3id.org/ontouml/vocabulary/docs","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ONTOUML","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/ontouml#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://w3id.org/ontouml/vocabulary","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A reference implementation of the OntoUML metamodel in OWL.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"RDF\",\"Methods\",\"Ontology-Driven Conceptual Modeling\",\"OntoUML\",\"OntoUML-Metamodel\"]","dct:title":"OntoUML Metamodel Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Semantics, Cybersecurity & Services (SCS), University of Twente, the Netherlands\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e6dcf0e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e6dcf0e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.utwente.nl/en/eemcs/scs/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"ontouml","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ONTOUML/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#UpperLevelOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2023-07-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ONTOUML&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ONTOUML/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ONTOUML/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2023-07-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ONTOUML/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ONTOUML&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ONTOUML/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ONTOUML/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ONTOUML","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":80.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ontouml","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/ontouml"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ONTOUML/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/ontouml/vocabulary/v1.0.0","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2528-3118\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2528-3118\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Claudenir M. Fonseca\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a1ad4300-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a1ad4300-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-5385-5761\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-5385-5761\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tiago Prince Sales\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c6533460-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c6533460-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2736-7817\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2736-7817\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pedro Paulo Favato Barcelos\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ee4a2190-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ee4a2190-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3385-4769\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3385-4769\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mattia Fumagalli\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d0198370-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d0198370-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ONTOUML/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"https://w3id.org/ontouml/vocabulary/v1.0.0","owl:versionInfo":"General review for compliance with the OntoUML Metamodel 1.1.1."},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"https://w3id.org/ontouml/metamodel/v1.1.1","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":273.44,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1235},"TRESIOT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://liidr.org/trust-recommendation-in-social-internet-of-things/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://liidr.org/trust-recommendation-in-social-internet-of-things/1.0.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"TRESIOT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://liidr.org/trust-recommendation-in-social-internet-of-things/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This ontology models trust recommendation concepts in SIoT to bridge the gap between abstract trust concepts and real-world device concepts.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"IoT\"]","dct:title":"Ontology for Trust Recommendation in Social Internet of Things","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Logistics Innovation and Information Dominance Research Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e5cc1360-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e5cc1360-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://liidr.org/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"tresiot","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TRESIOT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2023-05-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=TRESIOT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology models trust recommendation concepts in SIoT to bridge the gap between abstract trust concepts and real-world device concepts.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TRESIOT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TRESIOT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TRESIOT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=TRESIOT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TRESIOT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TRESIOT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TRESIOT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://liidr.org/trust-recommendation-in-social-internet-of-things/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://liidr.org/trust-recommendation-in-social-internet-of-things/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.33,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TRESIOT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.33,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5293-6140\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5293-6140\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Frank den Hartog\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b71ed810-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b71ed810-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-4439-1854\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-4439-1854\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elizabeth Chang\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c3536d00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c3536d00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-2935-465X\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-2935-465X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marius Becherer\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c8e074c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c8e074c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-5738-6560\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-5738-6560\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Omar Khadeer Hussain\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cff72db0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cff72db0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-8747-2603\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-8747-2603\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Yu Zhang\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e4f61a40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e4f61a40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TRESIOT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"1.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":273.33,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1950},"PUV":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/env/puv"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/nvs-vocabs/P01","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PUV","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/env/puv#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A simple ontology which implements the Parameter Usage Vocabulary semantic model, as described at https://github.com/nvs-vocabs/P01","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Environment\",\"Methods\"]","dct:title":"Parameter Usage Vocabulary ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PUV/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2021-03-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PUV&q=","schema:comment":"[\"A simple ontology which implements the Parameter Usage Vocabulary semantic model, as described at https://github.com/nvs-vocabs/P01\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PUV/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PUV/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2021-05-21T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PUV/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PUV&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PUV/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PUV/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PUV","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/env/puv","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/env/puv"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PUV/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-3884-3420\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-3884-3420\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Simon J D Cox\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d6071460-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d6071460-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-6559-4178\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-6559-4178\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gwenaëlle Moncoiffé\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9bd82ef0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9bd82ef0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-2237-0091\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-2237-0091\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jonathan Yu\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ac989790-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ac989790-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-8042-6391\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-8042-6391\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alexandra Kokkinaki\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c44701e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c44701e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"https://github.com/nvs-vocabs/P01\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PUV/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2021.0317"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":49.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":257.75,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1423},"PIMSII":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.molmod.info/semantics/pims-ii.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://www.molmod.info/semantics/pims-ii/II.1.12a/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PIMSII","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.molmod.info/semantics/pims-ii.ttl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Physicalistic Interpretation of Modelling and Simulation - Interoperability Infrastructure (PIMS-II) is a mid-level ontology with a focus on documenting cognitive processes and epistemic metadata","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"Physicalistic Interpretation of Modelling and Simulation - Interoperability Infrastructure (PIMS-II)","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Innovation Centre for Process Data Technology (Inprodat e.V.)\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a2843c00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a2843c00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.inprodat.de\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"pims-ii","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PIMSII/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2023-05-09T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PIMSII&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PIMSII/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PIMSII/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PIMSII/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PIMSII&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PIMSII/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PIMSII/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PIMSII","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":76.0,"normalizedScore":67,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.molmod.info/semantics/pims-ii.ttl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.molmod.info/semantics/pims-ii.ttl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PIMSII/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://www.gnu.org/licenses/lgpl-3.0.en.html","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://www.gnu.org/licenses/lgpl-3.0.en.html"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-9464-6739\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-9464-6739\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Martin Thomas Horsch\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/99f56900-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/99f56900-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PIMSII/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2023-05-09"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":271.44,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1552},"PSH":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ns.inria.fr/probabilistic-shacl/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://ns.inria.fr/probabilistic-shacl/psh.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PSH","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://ns.inria.fr/probabilistic-shacl/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An OWL vocabulary to include and exploit probabilistic information in SHACL validation reports","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"RDF\",\"Quality\"]","dct:title":"Probabilistic SHACL Validation","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institut National de Recherche en Informatique et en Automatique\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/99b0a5f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/99b0a5f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/National_Institute_for_Research_in_Computer_Science_and_Control\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"INRIA\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"02kvxyf05\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ROR:02kvxyf05\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"INRIA\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c69d09c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c69d09c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/National_Institute_for_Research_in_Computer_Science_and_Control\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"psh","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PSH/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2023-03-16T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PSH&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This vocabulary defines terms used to include and exploit probabilistic information in SHACL validation reports\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PSH/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PSH/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PSH/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PSH&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PSH/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PSH/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PSH","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ns.inria.fr/probabilistic-shacl/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ns.inria.fr/probabilistic-shacl/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PSH/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5959-5561\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5959-5561\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Catherine Faron Zucker\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d835fc10-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d835fc10-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Rémi Felin\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0bb16e60-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0bb16e60-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PSH/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":256.44,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":440},"RML-CC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/rml/cc/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://w3id.org/rml/cc"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RML-CC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://w3id.org/rml/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"RML module to generate RDF collections and containers","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"RDF\",\"W3C Rec\"]","dct:title":"RML-Containers","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"KNOWLEDGE GRAPH CONSTRUCTION COMMUNITY GROUP\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ae2824c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ae2824c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.w3.org/community/kg-construct/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"rml","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-CC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2023-06-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RML-CC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-CC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-CC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2023-06-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-CC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RML-CC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-CC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-CC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-CC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/rml/cc/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/rml/cc/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.13,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.13,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-CC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.13,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-9064-0463\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-9064-0463\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Franck MICHEL\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/77c1c960-da68-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/77c1c960-da68-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5375-8024\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5375-8024\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Iglesias Molina\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/2cbeb5f0-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/2cbeb5f0-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Christophe Debruyne\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/2cd50d70-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/2cd50d70-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-CC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/W3C"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":258.13,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2439},"RML-IO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/rml/io/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://w3id.org/rml/io"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RML-IO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://w3id.org/rml/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"RML-IO enables the description of input data sources and target output data serialization","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"RDF\",\"W3C Rec\"]","dct:title":"RML-IO: Source and Target","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"KNOWLEDGE GRAPH CONSTRUCTION COMMUNITY GROUP\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ae2824c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ae2824c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.w3.org/community/kg-construct/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"rml","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-IO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2023-06-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RML-IO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-IO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-IO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2023-06-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-IO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RML-IO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-IO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-IO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-IO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/rml/io/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/rml/io/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.13,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.13,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-IO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.13,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2138-7972\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2138-7972\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Anastasia Dimou\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/77801ef0-da68-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/77801ef0-da68-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dylan Van Assche\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/77b3b130-da68-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/77b3b130-da68-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5375-8024\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5375-8024\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Iglesias Molina\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/2cbeb5f0-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/2cbeb5f0-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pano Maria\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/3718ac40-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/3718ac40-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-IO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/W3C"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":258.13,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2559},"RML-STAR":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/rml/star/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://w3id.org/rml/star"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RML-STAR","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://w3id.org/rml/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"RML module for generating RDF-star graphs","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"RDF\",\"W3C Rec\"]","dct:title":"RML-star","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"KNOWLEDGE GRAPH CONSTRUCTION COMMUNITY GROUP\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ae2824c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ae2824c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.w3.org/community/kg-construct/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"rml","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-STAR/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2023-06-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RML-STAR&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-STAR/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-STAR/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2023-06-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-STAR/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RML-STAR&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-STAR/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-STAR/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-STAR","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/rml/star/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://w3id.org/rml/star/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.13,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.13,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-STAR/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.13,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://purl.org/NET/rdflicense/cc-by4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-2138-7972\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-2138-7972\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Anastasia Dimou\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/77801ef0-da68-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/77801ef0-da68-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5375-8024\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5375-8024\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ana Iglesias Molina\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/2cbeb5f0-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/2cbeb5f0-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3236-2789\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3236-2789\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"David Chaves Fraga\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b63b1d40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b63b1d40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-3029-6469\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-3029-6469\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Julián Arenas Guerrero\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/da7c0f30-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/da7c0f30-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RML-STAR/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/W3C"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.13,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2255},"CNT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2011/content"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.w3.org/TR/Content-in-RDF10/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CNT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/2011/content#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://www.w3.org/WAI/intro/earl","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Representing Content in RDF as defined by http://www.w3.org/TR/Content-in-RDF/","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"RDF\"]","dct:title":"Representing Content in RDF","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"W3C\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"W3C\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.w3.org/data#W3C\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CNT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2011-05-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CNT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Representing Content in RDF as defined by http://www.w3.org/TR/Content-in-RDF/\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CNT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CNT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CNT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CNT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CNT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CNT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CNT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2011/content","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2011/content"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://purl.org/dc/terms/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://purl.org/dc/terms/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CNT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CNT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Working Draft 29 April 2011"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/W3C"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":244.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":358},"RBDOC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/riverbench/schema/documentation"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://w3id.org/riverbench/schema/documentation/dev"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RBDOC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"https://w3id.org/riverbench/schema/documentation#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology with metadata needed to generate documentation of datasets, distributions, profiles, etc. in RiverBench","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\",\"Catalogs\"]","dct:title":"RiverBench documentation ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"rbdoc","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RBDOC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2023-05-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RBDOC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RBDOC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RBDOC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RBDOC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RBDOC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RBDOC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RBDOC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RBDOC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":74.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/riverbench/schema/documentation","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"https://w3id.org/riverbench/schema/documentation"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/riverbench/schema/metadata/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://schema.org/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, https://w3id.org/riverbench/schema/documentation]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.5,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"https://w3id.org/riverbench/schema/metadata/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RBDOC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/CC-BY-4.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.5,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"https://spdx.org/licenses/CC-BY-4.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-2543-9461\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-2543-9461\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Piotr Sowi?ski\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a0123e70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a0123e70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RBDOC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2023-05-08"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":268.5,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1477},"XAPI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/xapi/ontology#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/adlnet/xAPI-Spec/blob/1.0.3/xAPI.md","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"XAPI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/xapi/ontology#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This ontology contains a list of the classes and properties that can be used when for creating and publishing a controlled vocabulary dataset for xAPI communities of practice.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"API\"]","dct:title":"xAPI Controlled Vocabulary Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"xAPI Vocabulary Working Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b0d52a00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b0d52a00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"https://www.w3.org/community/xapivocabulary/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"xapi","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/XAPI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-04-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=XAPI&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology contains a list of the classes and properties that can be used when for creating and publishing a controlled vocabulary dataset for xAPI communities of practice.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/XAPI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/XAPI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2015-08-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/XAPI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=XAPI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/XAPI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/XAPI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/XAPI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/xapi/ontology#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/xapi/ontology#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://wordnet-rdf.princeton.edu/ontology#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://creativecommons.org/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://wordnet-rdf.princeton.edu/ontology#]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/XAPI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/XAPI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-08-13"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":262.44,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1357},"COLD":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/configurationontology"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"COLD","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/configurationontology#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology for the description of customizable products. It models the configuration process as the traversal of a graph of partially defined products, or \"Configurations\"","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"eBusiness\"]","dct:title":"'Configuration as Linked Data' ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"cold","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/COLD/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2013-11-21T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=COLD&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Ontology for the description of customizable products. It models the configuration process as the traversal of a graph of partially defined products, or \\\"Configurations\\\".\\n\\nRanges of customizable products are described rather effectively, for human users, by means of dedicated web applications called configurators. A configurator helps a user interactively define a product step by step, each step typically describing a valid partially defined product (or \\\"Configuration\\\"), with a start price and a list of remaining choices given all previous selections. Each of these choices links to another configuration until completion. Thus, the configuration process traverses a graph whose nodes are configurations. Now identify each configuration with a URI returning the list of the configurations it is linked to, among other relevant information: what you have is a description of the range as Linked Data.\\n\\nThe main classes of this ontology are Configuration (a state of the configuration process), Specification (a possible value of a characteristic of the configured product) and ConfigurationLink (which models a change of the state of the configuration process).\",\"Ontology for the description of customizable products. It models the configuration process as the traversal of a graph of partially defined products, or \\\"Configurations\\\".\\r\\n\\r\\nRanges of customizable products are described rather effectively, for human users, by means of dedicated web applications called configurators. A configurator helps a user interactively define a product step by step, each step typically describing a valid partially defined product (or \\\"Configuration\\\"), with a start price and a list of remaining choices given all previous selections. Each of these choices links to another configuration until completion. Thus, the configuration process traverses a graph whose nodes are configurations. Now identify each configuration with a URI returning the list of the configurations it is linked to, among other relevant information: what you have is a description of the range as Linked Data.\\r\\n\\r\\nThe main classes of this ontology are Configuration (a state of the configuration process), Specification (a possible value of a characteristic of the configured product) and ConfigurationLink (which models a change of the state of the configuration process).\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/COLD/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/COLD/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/COLD/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=COLD&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fr]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/COLD/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/COLD/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/COLD","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":65.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/configurationontology","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/configurationontology"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns, http://creativecommons.org/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.33,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/COLD/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.33,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Renault\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/92141ec0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/92141ec0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Renault\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"François-Paul Servant\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9940e040-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9940e040-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Edouard Chevalier\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e42bac70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e42bac70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/COLD/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2013-11-21"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":261.33,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1431},"EMP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ctic/empleo/oferta"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":3.0,"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[\"http://data.fundacionctic.org/vocab/empleo/oferta_20130903\"]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EMP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/ctic/empleo/oferta#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This is a vocabulary for modeling jobs offer in Spain.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Society\"]","dct:title":"A vocabulary for jobs","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CTIC\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"CTIC Foundation\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0164e170-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0164e170-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://data.semanticweb.org/organization/fundacion-ctic\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"emp","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2013-09-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=EMP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=EMP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/es]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ctic/empleo/oferta","dct:identifier":"[\"http://data.fundacionctic.org/vocab/empleo/oferta_20130903\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ctic/empleo/oferta"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[\"http://data.fundacionctic.org/vocab/empleo/oferta_20130903.html\",\"http://data.fundacionctic.org/vocab/empleo/oferta_20130903.rdf\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2006/03/wn/wn20/instances/\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://creativecommons.org/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2006/03/wn/wn20/instances/\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"http://purl.org/ctic/empleo/oferta","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[\"http://data.fundacionctic.org/vocab/empleo/oferta_20130903.html\",\"http://data.fundacionctic.org/vocab/empleo/oferta_20130903.rdf\"]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"http://purl.org/ctic/empleo/oferta","owl:versionInfo":"v2013-09-03"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":42.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":263.44,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1340},"AIISO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/schema"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":3.0,"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[\"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/schema-20080925\"]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://vocab.org/aiiso/schema-20080925.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"AIISO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/schema#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/usagenote.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Academic Institution Internal Structure Ontology (AIISO) provides classes and properties to describe the internal organizational structure of an academic institution. AIISO is designed to work in partnership with Participation (http://purl.org/vocab/participation/schema), FOAF (http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/) and aiiso-roles (http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso-roles/schema) to describe the roles that people play within an institution.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Academy\"]","dct:title":"Academic Institution Internal Structure Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"aiiso","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AIISO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2008-09-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=AIISO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"\\n\\t\\t\\tThe Academic Institution Internal Structure Ontology (AIISO) provides classes and properties to describe the internal organizational structure of an academic institution. AIISO is designed to work in partnership with Participation (http://purl.org/vocab/participation/schema), FOAF (http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/) and aiiso-roles (http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso-roles/schema) to describe the roles that people play within an institution.\\n    \\t\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AIISO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AIISO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AIISO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=AIISO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AIISO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AIISO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AIISO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":72.0,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/schema","dct:identifier":"[\"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/schema-20080925\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/schema"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[\"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/schema-20080925.html\",\"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/schema-20080925.rdf\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/spec/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns, http://web.resource.org/cc/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/spec/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AIISO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/schema#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[\"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/schema-20080925.html\",\"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/schema-20080925.rdf\"]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Nadeem Shabir\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8cc08670-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8cc08670-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Rob Styles\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8cd71550-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8cd71550-da5e-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/AIISO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"http://purl.org/vocab/aiiso/schema#","owl:versionInfo":"v2008-09-25"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.44,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1248},"GEOD":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.lenka.no/geo-deling"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://vocab.lenka.no/geo-deling.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"GEOD","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://vocab.lenka.no/geo-deling#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Vocabulary describing the administrative subdivision of Norway","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Geography\"]","dct:title":"Administrative vocabulary for Norway","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"geo-deling","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOD/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-10-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=GEOD&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOD/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOD/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2012-10-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOD/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=GEOD&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOD/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOD/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOD","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.lenka.no/geo-deling","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.lenka.no/geo-deling"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.5,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOD/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.5,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Kjetil Kjernsmo\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cdbd0ab0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cdbd0ab0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOD/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2012-10-11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":239.5,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":537},"ALGO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://securitytoolbox.appspot.com/securityAlgorithms#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ALGO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://securitytoolbox.appspot.com/securityAlgorithms#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An ontology describing cryptographic algorithms","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Security\"]","dct:title":"Algorithms Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"algo","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ALGO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-01-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ALGO&q=","schema:comment":"[\" An ontology to describe various cryptographic algorithms\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ALGO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ALGO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2014-01-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ALGO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ALGO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ALGO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ALGO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ALGO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":65.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://securitytoolbox.appspot.com/securityAlgorithms#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://securitytoolbox.appspot.com/securityAlgorithms#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://securitytoolbox.appspot.com/securityAssurance.owl#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns, http://creativecommons.org/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://securitytoolbox.appspot.com/securityAssurance.owl#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ALGO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jim Luo\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/93560f70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/93560f70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"luo@itd.nrl.navy.mil\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Anya Kim\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/99cf2d20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/99cf2d20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"kim@itd.nrl.navy.mil\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Myong Kang\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d6461db0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d6461db0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"mkang@itd.nrl.navy.mil\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Amélie Gyrard\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c42e1a80-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c42e1a80-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"gyrard@eurecom.fr\",\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[\"http://www.dtic.mil/cgi-bin/GetTRDoc?AD=ADA437938\"]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ALGO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-01-11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":28,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":49.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":256.44,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":518},"ADMS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.w3.org/TR/vocab-adms/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ADMS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"ADMS is a profile of DCAT, used to describe semantic assets (or just 'Assets'), defined as highly reusable metadata (e.g. xml schemata, generic data models) and reference data (e.g. code lists, taxonomies, dictionaries, vocabularies) that are used for eGovernment system development.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"Asset Description Metadata Schema","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"W3C\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"W3C\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.w3.org/data#W3C\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ADMS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-12-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-05-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ADMS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ADMS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ADMS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2015-07-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ADMS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ADMS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ADMS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ADMS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ADMS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat\",\"http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml/vocab\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/vocommons/voaf, http://www.w3.org/2007/05/powder-s]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ADMS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat\",\"http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml/vocab\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"The European Commission\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c63a4da0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c63a4da0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/European_Commission\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andrea Perego\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cf384fd0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cf384fd0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Phil Archer\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f3fa3250-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f3fa3250-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Makx Dekkers\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f6b2b600-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f6b2b600-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"The European Commission\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c63a4da0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c63a4da0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/European_Commission\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Phil Archer\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f3fa3250-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f3fa3250-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Makx Dekkers\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f6b2b600-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f6b2b600-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gofran Shukair\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fcaacb00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fcaacb00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ADMS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-07-22"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/W3C"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.44,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":380},"BLT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.bl.uk/schemas/bibliographic/blterms"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BLT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.bl.uk/schemas/bibliographic/blterms#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Some useful terms for describing bibliographic resources that other models did not include. Version 1.4: brings the description for this schema in line with \"Metadata recommendations for Linked Open Vocabulairies\", version 1.1.; dct:license replaced by cc:license and the value changed from http://www.opendatacommons.org/licenses/pddl/1.0/ to http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/; various typos corrected. Version 1.4.1: added links to previous schema versions","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Catalogs\"]","dct:title":"British Library Terms RDF schema","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"British Library, Metadata Services\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e5797fc0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e5797fc0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"metadata@bl.uk\",\"homepage\":\"mailto:metadata@bl.uk\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"blt","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BLT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2013-10-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=BLT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Some useful terms for describing bibliographic resources that other models did not include. Version 1.4: brings the description for this schema in line with \\\"Metadata recommendations for Linked Open Vocabulairies\\\", version 1.1.; dct:license replaced by cc:license and the value changed from http://www.opendatacommons.org/licenses/pddl/1.0/ to http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/; various typos corrected. Version 1.4.1: added links to previous schema versions\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BLT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BLT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2013-10-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BLT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=BLT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BLT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BLT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BLT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.bl.uk/schemas/bibliographic/blterms","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.bl.uk/schemas/bibliographic/blterms"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/event.owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://creativecommons.org/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.33,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BLT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://purl.org/NET/c4dm/event.owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"http://www.bl.uk/schemas/bibliographic/blterms-v1-2.rdf","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.33,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/mark/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Heather Rosie\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b383a190-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b383a190-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"Heather.Rosie@bl.uk\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alan Danskin\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc96ad20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc96ad20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jan Ashton\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c2be07e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c2be07e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"Jan.Ashton@bl.uk\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Corine Deliot\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e6c636c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e6c636c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tim Hodson\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/10e7de00-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/10e7de00-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BLT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"http://www.bl.uk/schemas/bibliographic/blterms-v1-2.rdf","owl:versionInfo":"v1.41"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.33,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":548},"C4O":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/spar/c4o"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"C4O","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/spar/c4o/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"C4O allows the characterization of bibliographic citations in terms of their number and their context.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"SPAR\"]","dct:title":"C4O, the Citation Counting and Context Characterization Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/C4O/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2013-05-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=C4O&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is available at http://purl.org/spar/c4o, and uses the namespace prefix c4o.  Other SPAR ontologies are described at http://purl.org/spar/.\",\"The Citation Counting and Context Characterization Ontology (C4O) is an ontology for characterizing the number and contexts of bibliographic citations.  It forms part of SPAR, a suite of Semantic Publishing and Referencing Ontologies.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/C4O/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/C4O/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/C4O/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=C4O&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/C4O/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/C4O/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/C4O","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/spar/c4o","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/spar/c4o"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://purl.org/spar/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/spar/biro, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema, http://purl.org/vocab/frbr/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://purl.org/co\",\"http://purl.org/vocab/frbr/core\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://purl.org/spar/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/spar/biro, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema, http://purl.org/vocab/frbr/core]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/C4O/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://purl.org/co\",\"http://purl.org/vocab/frbr/core\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-5506-523X\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-5506-523X\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"David Shotton\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d11ff520-da63-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d11ff520-da63-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0530-4305\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0530-4305\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Silvio Peroni\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ced144a0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ced144a0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/C4O/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/SPAR"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.75,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1287},"SMG":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ns.cerise-project.nl/energy/def/cim-smartgrid"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SMG","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://ns.cerise-project.nl/energy/def/cim-smartgrid#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://www.iec.ch/smartgrid/standards/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A Profile of the IEC Common Information Model for Smart Grids, developed by the Cerise-SG project.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Industry\"]","dct:title":"CERISE CIM Profile for Smart Grids","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"CERISE-SG\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0781f9a0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0781f9a0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.cerise-project.nl/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SMG/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2014-05-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SMG&q=","schema:comment":"[\"A Profile of the IEC Common Information Model for Smart Grids, developed by the Cerise-SG project.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SMG/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SMG/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SMG/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SMG&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SMG/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SMG/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SMG","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ns.cerise-project.nl/energy/def/cim-smartgrid","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ns.cerise-project.nl/energy/def/cim-smartgrid"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://langdale.com.au/2005/UML#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.75,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SMG/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":43.75,"normalizedScore":40,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Maarten Steen\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b16c6710-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b16c6710-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SMG/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2014-05-22"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/IEC"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":233.75,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":247},"CSP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.deri.ie/csp"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://vocab.deri.ie/csp.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CSP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://vocab.deri.ie/csp#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A vocabulary to represent Constraint Satisfaction Problems (CSPs) in which constraints are expressed by Boolean expressions on fluents.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Industry\"]","dct:title":"Constraint Satisfaction Problems Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"csp","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CSP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2011-06-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CSP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CSP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CSP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2011-06-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CSP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CSP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CSP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CSP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CSP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.deri.ie/csp","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.deri.ie/csp"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/adms, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.5,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CSP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.5,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"François-Paul Servant\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9940e040-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9940e040-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Fadi Badra\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e0eebc80-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e0eebc80-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alexandre Passant\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0c40f380-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0c40f380-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CSP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2011-06-29"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":239.5,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6333},"CPA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/cpannotationschema.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CPA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/cpannotationschema.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A set of annotation properties to be used for ontology design patterns","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"Content Pattern Annotations","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CPA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2009-06-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CPA&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CPA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CPA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CPA/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CPA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CPA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CPA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CPA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/cpannotationschema.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/cpannotationschema.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.75,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CPA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":43.75,"normalizedScore":40,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CPA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2009-06-02"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":241.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":443},"CTXDESC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.demcare.eu/ontologies/contextdescriptor.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://www.demcare.eu/ontologies/contextdescriptor.owl/1.0"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.demcare.eu/ontologies/ctxdesc.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CTXDESC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.demcare.eu/ontologies/contextdescriptor.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://www.demcare.eu/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"OWL pattern for describing activity models as abstract dependencies among classes.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"Context Descriptor Pattern","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"ctxdesc","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CTXDESC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-09-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CTXDESC&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The ontology provides the vocabulary to annotate complex (high-level) activity classes with low-level observations for complex activity recognition.\\n\\nDocumentation regarding the ontology vocabulary can be found at http://www.demcare.eu/ontologies/ctxdesc.html\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CTXDESC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CTXDESC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2015-09-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CTXDESC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CTXDESC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CTXDESC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CTXDESC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CTXDESC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":73.0,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.demcare.eu/ontologies/contextdescriptor.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.demcare.eu/ontologies/contextdescriptor.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/DUL.owl#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://creativecommons.org/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.33,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CTXDESC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/DUL.owl#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.33,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Georgios Meditskos\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e1efb8a0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e1efb8a0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CTXDESC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":265.33,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":627},"D2RQ":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.wiwiss.fu-berlin.de/suhl/bizer/D2RQ/0.1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://d2rq.org/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"D2RQ","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.wiwiss.fu-berlin.de/suhl/bizer/D2RQ/0.1#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This document specifies the D2RQ mapping language. D2RQ is a declarative language to describe mappings between relational database schemata and OWL/RDFS ontologies.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"RDF\"]","dct:title":"D2RQ - Language Specification","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/D2RQ/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-12-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2004-06-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=D2RQ&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This document specifies the D2RQ mapping language. D2RQ is a declarative language to describe mappings between relational database schemata and OWL/RDFS ontologies.  See D2RQ Users Manual for detailed explanations and examples (http://www.wiwiss.fu-berlin.de/suhl/bizer/d2rq/spec/).\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/D2RQ/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/D2RQ/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2009-02-19T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/D2RQ/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=D2RQ&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/D2RQ/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/D2RQ/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/D2RQ","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.wiwiss.fu-berlin.de/suhl/bizer/D2RQ/0.1","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.wiwiss.fu-berlin.de/suhl/bizer/D2RQ/0.1"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://jena.hpl.hp.com/2005/11/Assembler#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://jena.hpl.hp.com/2005/11/Assembler#, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/D2RQ/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://jena.hpl.hp.com/2005/11/Assembler#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/D2RQ/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.6"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":564},"DCTYPE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/dc/dcmitype/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://dublincore.org/documents/dcmi-type-vocabulary","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DCTYPE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/dc/dcmitype/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The DCMI Type Vocabulary provides a general, cross-domain list of approved terms that may be used as values for the Resource Type element to identify the genre of a resource.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"General & Upper\"]","dct:title":"DCMI Type Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dublin Core Metadata Initiative\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0ef7b000-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0ef7b000-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://purl.org/dc/aboutdcmi#DCMI\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DCTYPE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2000-07-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=DCTYPE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DCTYPE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DCTYPE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2012-06-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DCTYPE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=DCTYPE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DCTYPE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DCTYPE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DCTYPE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/dc/dcmitype/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/dc/dcmitype/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/dcam/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.75,"normalizedScore":17,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DCTYPE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.75,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dublin Core Metadata Initiative\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0ef7b000-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0ef7b000-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://purl.org/dc/aboutdcmi#DCMI\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DCTYPE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2012-06-14"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/DCMI"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":244.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1255},"DRM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.data.gov/def/drm"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://vocab.data.gov/def/drm.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DRM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://vocab.data.gov/def/drm#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://vocab.data.gov/def/drm.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A metamodel for government data","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"General & Upper\"]","dct:title":"Data Reference Model","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Federal government of the United States\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f1645920-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f1645920-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Federal_government_of_the_United_States\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"drm","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DRM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-03-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=DRM&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DRM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DRM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2012-03-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DRM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=DRM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DRM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DRM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DRM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.data.gov/def/drm","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.data.gov/def/drm"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://vocab.data.gov/def/fea\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DRM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://vocab.data.gov/def/fea\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DRM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2012-03-17"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.44,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":216},"IDEMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdf.insee.fr/def/demo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IDEMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdf.insee.fr/def/demo#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology with classes and properties used for demography, mostly in the census of the population","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Methods\"]","dct:title":"Demographic ontology from the French Statistics Institute","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"INSEE\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8f5e01a0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8f5e01a0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/INSEE\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"idemo","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDEMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-12-26T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=IDEMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDEMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDEMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2012-12-26T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDEMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=IDEMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fr","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDEMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDEMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDEMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdf.insee.fr/def/demo","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdf.insee.fr/def/demo"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://rdf.insee.fr/def/geo, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/adms, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://creativecommons.org/ns, http://purl.org/vocommons/voaf]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://rdf.insee.fr/def/geo, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDEMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://www.data.gouv.fr/Licence-Ouverte-Open-Licence","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://www.data.gouv.fr/Licence-Ouverte-Open-Licence"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Franck Cotton\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a7af5df0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a7af5df0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDEMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":256.44,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":458},"DAIA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/daia"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/gbv/daia/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"DAIA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/ontology/daia/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Document Availability Information Ontology (DAIA) describes the current availability of documents in libraries and similar institutions. Availability can be expressed in terms of specific services.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Catalogs\"]","dct:title":"Document Availability Information Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DAIA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2011-12-15T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=DAIA&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DAIA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DAIA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DAIA/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=DAIA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DAIA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DAIA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DAIA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/daia","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/daia"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema, http://purl.org/vocab/frbr/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://purl.org/dc/dcmitype/\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns, http://www.w3.org/2008/05/skos#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema, http://purl.org/vocab/frbr/core]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DAIA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://purl.org/dc/dcmitype/\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jakob Voß\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/268a3150-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/268a3150-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/DAIA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2011-12-15"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":247.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1226},"EBUCORE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ebu.ch/metadata/ontologies/ebucore/ebucore"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://tech.ebu.ch/lang/en/MetadataEbuCore","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EBUCORE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.ebu.ch/metadata/ontologies/ebucore/ebucore#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[\"http://www.ebu.ch/metadata/ontologies/ebucore/20150122/ebucore_2015_05_20.rdf\"]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Combined with the EBU Class Conceptual Data Model (CCDM) of simple business objects, EBUCore provides the appropriate framework for descriptive and technical metadata for use in Service Oriented Architectures and also in audiovisual ontologies for semantic web and linked data developments.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Multimedia\"]","dct:title":"EBU Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EBUCORE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-08-04T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=EBUCORE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EBUCORE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EBUCORE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2015-08-04T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EBUCORE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=EBUCORE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EBUCORE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EBUCORE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EBUCORE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ebu.ch/metadata/ontologies/ebucore/ebucore","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ebu.ch/metadata/ontologies/ebucore/ebucore"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.bbc.co.uk/ontologies/coreconcepts, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/ns/ma-ont]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://www.bbc.co.uk/ontologies/coreconcepts\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\"]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.bbc.co.uk/ontologies/coreconcepts\",\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns, http://creativecommons.org/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":20.44,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.bbc.co.uk/ontologies/coreconcepts, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EBUCORE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.bbc.co.uk/ontologies/coreconcepts\",\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://www.bbc.co.uk/ontologies/coreconcepts\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\"]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"http://www.ebu.ch/metadata/ontologies/ebucore/20150122/ebucore_2015_05_20.rdf","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[\"http://www.ebu.ch/metadata/ontologies/ebucore/20150122/ebucore_2015_05_20.rdf\"]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/ns/ma-ont]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":60.44,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EBUCORE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"http://www.ebu.ch/metadata/ontologies/ebucore/20150122/ebucore_2015_05_20.rdf","owl:versionInfo":"Version 1.6"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":247.44,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":366},"EDAC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-edac.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/ontologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EDAC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-edac.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The ELSEWeb EDAC ontology describes datasets published by EDAC. This project provides foundational support for the ELSEWeb project(http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/).\nwebsite: http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/ontologies\nemail: nvillanuevarosales@utep.edu","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Catalogs\",\"Support\"]","dct:title":"ELSEWeb EDAC Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"ELSEWeb Team\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e27ae770-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e27ae770-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://cybershare.utep.edu\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"elseweb-edac","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EDAC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-09-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=EDAC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EDAC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EDAC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2015-09-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EDAC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=EDAC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EDAC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EDAC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EDAC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-edac.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-edac.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-data.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-data.owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://semanticscience.org/ontology/sio.owl, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://creativecommons.org/ns, http://protege.stanford.edu/plugins/owl/protege#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.44,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-data.owl]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EDAC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-data.owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.44,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Nicholas del Rio\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d985d9e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d985d9e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Natalia Villanueva-Rosales\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/03afbc60-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/03afbc60-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EDAC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/projects/ELSEWEB, created=2026-01-27T16:16:38.000+01:00, creator=[https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/jonquet], updated=2026-01-27T16:16:38.000+01:00, acronym=ELSEWEB, description=The Earth, Life and Semantic Web (ELSeWeb) project integrates the NASA-funded Earth Data Analysis Center with an analytical Web Service platform, Lifemapper, which models potential future species distributions under scenarios of climate change. The integrated system provides climate change impact scientists streamlined mechanisms for discovering, accessing, understanding, and using Earth observation data to model future species projection scenarios., contacts=Deana D Pennington (ddpennington@utep.edu), homePage=http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/, institution=University of Texas, ontologyUsed=[https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EDAC, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWPM, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSMAP, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWEB, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWMO], name=Earth, Life and Semantic Web, @id=https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/projects/ELSEWEB, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":281.44,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1467},"LSWPM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-lifemapper-parameters.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/ontologies","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"LSWPM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-lifemapper-parameters.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The ELSEWeb Lifemapper parameters ontology provides auxiliary classes and instances that describe input parameters of Lifemapper modelling services. This ontology provides support for the ELSEWeb project(http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/).\nwebsite: http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/ontologies\nemail: nvillanuevarosales@utep.edu, The ELSEWeb Lifemapper parameters ontology provides auxiliary classes and instances that describe input parameters of Lifemapper modelling services. This ontology provides support for the ELSEWeb project(http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/).\nwebsite: http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/ontologies\nemail: nvillanuevarosales@utep.edu\n","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Support\"]","dct:title":"ELSEWeb Lifemapper Parameters Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"ELSEWeb Team\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e27ae770-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e27ae770-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://cybershare.utep.edu\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"elseweb-lifemapper-parameters","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWPM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-09-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=LSWPM&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWPM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWPM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2015-09-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWPM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=LSWPM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWPM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWPM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWPM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":78.0,"normalizedScore":69,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://semanticscience.org/ontology/sio.owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat, http://www.w3.org/ns/, http://semanticscience.org/ontology/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-lifemapper.owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://creativecommons.org/ns, http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-modelling.owl, http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-lifemapper.owl, http://protege.stanford.edu/plugins/owl/protege#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://semanticscience.org/ontology/sio.owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat, http://www.w3.org/ns/, http://semanticscience.org/ontology/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWPM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-lifemapper.owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o-20130312","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Nicholas del Rio\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d985d9e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d985d9e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Natalia Villanueva-Rosales\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/03afbc60-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/03afbc60-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWPM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o-20130312","owl:versionInfo":"v1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/projects/ELSEWEB, created=2026-01-27T16:16:38.000+01:00, creator=[https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/jonquet], updated=2026-01-27T16:16:38.000+01:00, acronym=ELSEWEB, description=The Earth, Life and Semantic Web (ELSeWeb) project integrates the NASA-funded Earth Data Analysis Center with an analytical Web Service platform, Lifemapper, which models potential future species distributions under scenarios of climate change. The integrated system provides climate change impact scientists streamlined mechanisms for discovering, accessing, understanding, and using Earth observation data to model future species projection scenarios., contacts=Deana D Pennington (ddpennington@utep.edu), homePage=http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/, institution=University of Texas, ontologyUsed=[https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EDAC, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWPM, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSMAP, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWEB, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWMO], name=Earth, Life and Semantic Web, @id=https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/projects/ELSEWEB, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":270.44,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":694},"LSMAP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/mappings/elseweb-mappings.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-mappings.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":25.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"LSMAP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/elseweb-data.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The ELSEWeb mappings ontology imports related upper level ontologies and vocabularies and aligns ELSEWeb ontologies to importec classes. This ontology provides support for the ELSEWeb project(http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/).\nwebsite: http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/ontologies\nemail: nvillanuevarosales@utep.edu","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Support\"]","dct:title":"ELSEWeb Mappings Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"ELSEWeb Team\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e27ae770-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e27ae770-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://cybershare.utep.edu\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"elseweb-mappings","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSMAP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-09-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=LSMAP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSMAP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSMAP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2015-09-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSMAP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=LSMAP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSMAP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSMAP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSMAP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":71.0,"normalizedScore":62,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/mappings/elseweb-mappings.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/mappings/elseweb-mappings.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/, http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.0/, http://www.w3.org/ns/, http://semanticscience.org/ontology/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://semanticscience.org/ontology/sio.owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat\",\"http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.0/oboe-core.owl#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://semanticscience.org/ontology/sio.owl, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://creativecommons.org/ns, http://protege.stanford.edu/plugins/owl/protege#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#, http://ontology.cybershare.utep.edu/ELSEWeb/, http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.0/, http://www.w3.org/ns/, http://semanticscience.org/ontology/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSMAP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://semanticscience.org/ontology/sio.owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat\",\"http://ecoinformatics.org/oboe/oboe.1.0/oboe-core.owl#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Nicholas del Rio\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d985d9e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d985d9e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Natalia Villanueva-Rosales\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/03afbc60-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/03afbc60-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSMAP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-09-24"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"{id=https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/projects/ELSEWEB, created=2026-01-27T16:16:38.000+01:00, creator=[https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/jonquet], updated=2026-01-27T16:16:38.000+01:00, acronym=ELSEWEB, description=The Earth, Life and Semantic Web (ELSeWeb) project integrates the NASA-funded Earth Data Analysis Center with an analytical Web Service platform, Lifemapper, which models potential future species distributions under scenarios of climate change. The integrated system provides climate change impact scientists streamlined mechanisms for discovering, accessing, understanding, and using Earth observation data to model future species projection scenarios., contacts=Deana D Pennington (ddpennington@utep.edu), homePage=http://elseweb.cybershare.utep.edu/, institution=University of Texas, ontologyUsed=[https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EDAC, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWPM, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSMAP, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWEB, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LSWMO], name=Earth, Life and Semantic Web, @id=https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/projects/ELSEWEB, @type=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Project, @context={@vocab=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/, acronym=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/acronym, creator={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User, @type=@id}, created=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/created, updated=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/updated, name=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/name, homePage=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/homePage, description=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/description, contacts=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/contacts, institution=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/institution, ontologyUsed={@id=http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/Ontology, @type=@id}, @language=en}}","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":30,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":50.0,"normalizedScore":34,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":278.44,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1516},"EMOTION":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ns.inria.fr/emoca"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://ns.inria.fr/emoca/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EMOTION","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://ns.inria.fr/emoca#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"EmOCA is used to contextualize dimensionnal emotion and to categorize it for human readability.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"People\"]","dct:title":"Emotion Ontology for Context Awareness","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institut National de Recherche en Informatique et en Automatique\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/99b0a5f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/99b0a5f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/National_Institute_for_Research_in_Computer_Science_and_Control\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"INRIA\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"02kvxyf05\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ROR:02kvxyf05\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"INRIA\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c69d09c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c69d09c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/National_Institute_for_Research_in_Computer_Science_and_Control\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"emotion","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMOTION/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2013-11-26T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=EMOTION&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMOTION/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMOTION/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2013-11-26T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMOTION/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=EMOTION&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMOTION/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMOTION/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMOTION","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ns.inria.fr/emoca","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ns.inria.fr/emoca"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://creativecommons.org/ns, http://purl.org/vocommons/voaf]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMOTION/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institut National de Recherche en Informatique et en Automatique\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/99b0a5f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/99b0a5f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/National_Institute_for_Research_in_Computer_Science_and_Control\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Franck Berthelon\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bfdcca40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bfdcca40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"INRIA\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"02kvxyf05\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ROR:02kvxyf05\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"INRIA\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c69d09c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c69d09c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/National_Institute_for_Research_in_Computer_Science_and_Control\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Peter Sander\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f199e830-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f199e830-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-1562-6922\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-1562-6922\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ghislain Atemezing\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d3de2660-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d3de2660-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Fabien Gandon\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f2d3cea0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f2d3cea0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EMOTION/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2013-11-26"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":258.44,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":584},"EARL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/earl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.w3.org/TR/EARL10/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"EARL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/ns/earl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://www.w3.org/TR/HTTP-in-RDF/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"EARL is a vocabulary, the terms of which are defined across a set of specifications and technical notes, and that is used to describe test results. The primary motivation for developing this vocabulary is to facilitate the exchange of test results between Web accessibility evaluation tools in a vendor-neutral and platform-independent format. It also provides reusable terms for generic quality assurance and validation purposes.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Quality\"]","dct:title":"Evaluation and Report Language","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"W3C\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"W3C\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.w3.org/data#W3C\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EARL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2011-05-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=EARL&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Formal schema of the Evaluation and Report Language (EARL) 1.0\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EARL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EARL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EARL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=EARL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EARL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EARL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EARL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/earl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/earl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2009/pointers#, http://www.w3.org/ns/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://usefulinc.com/ns/doap#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/spec/#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2009/pointers#, http://www.w3.org/ns/]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EARL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://usefulinc.com/ns/doap#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/spec/#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"W3C Evaluation and Repair Tools Working Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/db984470-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/db984470-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.w3.org/WAI/ER/\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/EARL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2011-05-10"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/W3C"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":390},"RDAFRBR":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDAFRBR","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Defines the core RDA classes, including FRBR levels Work, Expression, Manifestation and Item.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"FRBR\"]","dct:title":"FRBR Entities for RDA","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAFRBR/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-03-26T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAFRBR&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAFRBR/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAFRBR/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAFRBR/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAFRBR&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAFRBR/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAFRBR/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAFRBR","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/RegAp/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.75,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAFRBR/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":43.75,"normalizedScore":40,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Metadata Management Associates\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf395bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf395bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://managemetadata.com/\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAFRBR/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2012-03-26"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/RDA, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/FRBR]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1740},"OFRD":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/opdm/refrigerator#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OFRD","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/opdm/refrigerator#","dct:subject":"[\"refrigerator fridge freezer\"]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Vocabulary to describe fridges and freezers","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Industry\"]","dct:title":"Fridge and Freezer Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFRD/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2014-08-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=OFRD&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Vocabulary to describe fridges and freezers\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFRD/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFRD/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFRD/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=OFRD&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/de, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/es]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFRD/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFRD/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFRD","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/opdm/refrigerator#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/opdm/refrigerator#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/opdm/utility#, http://purl.org/goodrelations/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://purl.org/opdm/utility#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/opdm/utility#, http://purl.org/goodrelations/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFRD/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[\"refrigerator fridge freezer\"]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"OPDM project\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d529bf00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d529bf00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://opdm-project.org/\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"E-Business and Web Science Research Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f3a76880-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f3a76880-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.unibw.de/ebusiness/\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OFRD/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2014-08-18"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.75,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1223},"GTFS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.gtfs.org/terms#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/OpenTransport/vocabulary/master/gtfs/gtfs.ttl","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"GTFS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://vocab.gtfs.org/terms#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"https://developers.google.com/transit/gtfs/reference","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This ontology is a translation of the General Transit Feed Specification towards URIs. Its intended use is creating an exchange platform where the Linked GTFS model can be used as a start to get the right data into the right format.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Travel\"]","dct:title":"General Transit Feed Specification","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"gtfs","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GTFS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2014-10-27T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=GTFS&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GTFS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GTFS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GTFS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=GTFS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GTFS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GTFS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GTFS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.gtfs.org/terms#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.gtfs.org/terms#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"http://vocab.org/transit/terms/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://schema.org/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.33,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GTFS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://schema.org/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/dcat\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"http://vocab.org/transit/terms/","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.33,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Pieter Colpaert\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/98930ab0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/98930ab0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andrew Byrd\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ea5af620-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ea5af620-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GTFS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2014-10-27"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":246.33,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":392},"RDFG":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/rdfg-1/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDFG","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/rdfg-1/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Properties allowing statement of intensional equivalence between RDF graphs","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"RDF\"]","dct:title":"Graph","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"W3C\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"W3C\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.w3.org/data#W3C\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDFG/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2004-12-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDFG&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDFG/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDFG/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDFG/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDFG&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDFG/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDFG/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDFG","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/rdfg-1/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/rdfg-1/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.75,"normalizedScore":17,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDFG/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.75,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDFG/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2004-12-31"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/W3C"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":232.75,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":390},"SWP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/swp-1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SWP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/swp-1/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This vocabulary allows to attach an authority to a named graph","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"RDF\"]","dct:title":"Graph Authority","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"W3C\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"W3C\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.w3.org/data#W3C\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SWP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2004-03-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SWP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SWP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SWP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SWP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SWP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SWP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SWP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SWP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/swp-1","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/swp-1"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/rdfg-1/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/rdfg-1/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SWP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SWP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2004-03-01"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/W3C"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":235.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":398},"HTTP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2011/http"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"HTTP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/2011/http#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://www.w3.org/TR/Content-in-RDF/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A namespace for describing HTTP messages (http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616.html)","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"API\"]","dct:title":"HTTP in RDF","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"W3C\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"W3C\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.w3.org/data#W3C\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HTTP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2011-04-29T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=HTTP&q=","schema:comment":"[\"A namespace for describing HTTP messages (http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616.html)\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HTTP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HTTP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HTTP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=HTTP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HTTP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HTTP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HTTP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2011/http","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2011/http"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2011/content]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2011/content, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2011/content]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2011/content, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HTTP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HTTP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"Working Draft 29 April 2011"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/W3C"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":376},"HDO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.samos.gr/ontologies/helpdeskOnto.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.samos.gr/ontologies/helpdeskOnto.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"HDO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.samos.gr/ontologies/helpdeskOnto.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Simple ontology developed for integration purposes. Describe helpdesk entities used to record support tickets for diagnosis and resolve purpuses. The ontology re-uses a) W3C ORG and REGORG ontologies, b) DUL upper ontology, and c) GoodRelations ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Support\"]","dct:title":"HelpDesk support Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"hdo","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HDO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2013-04-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=HDO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HDO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HDO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2013-04-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HDO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=HDO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/el, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HDO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HDO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HDO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.samos.gr/ontologies/helpdeskOnto.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.samos.gr/ontologies/helpdeskOnto.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/org#, http://www.w3.org/ns/regorg#, http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/, http://purl.org/goodrelations/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/regorg\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#\",\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.54,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/org#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://schema.org/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.54,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/org#, http://www.w3.org/ns/regorg#, http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/, http://purl.org/goodrelations/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HDO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/regorg\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#\",\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.54,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Konstantinos Kotis\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8c9d43b0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8c9d43b0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Christopher Gutteridge\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f0a88570-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f0a88570-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Nikos Loutas\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f2f2ecf0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f2f2ecf0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/HDO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"0.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":246.54,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":413},"ISO-THES":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/iso25964/skos-thes"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ISO-THES","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/iso25964/skos-thes#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://www.niso.org/schemas/iso25964/correspondencesSKOS/","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This vocabulary aims at providing interoperability between SKOS and ISO 25964 ? 1:2011, the new standard for thesauri","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Vocabularies\"]","dct:title":"ISO 25964 SKOS extension","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ISO-THES/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-03-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ISO-THES&q=","schema:comment":"[\"These notes apply to the published mapping between the ISO 25964 data model and the SKOS schema (http://www.niso.org/schemas/iso25964/correspondencesSKOS/).\\nRemarks can be exchanged using: 25964info@list.niso.org \\nSubscription info and archive is on: http://www.niso.org/lists/25964info/ \\nGeneral information about ISO 25964: http://www.niso.org/schemas/iso25964/\\n\\nThe annotation http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns#term_status indicates \\\"proposed\\\" properties that are not part of the mapping documentation.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ISO-THES/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ISO-THES/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2015-03-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ISO-THES/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ISO-THES&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ISO-THES/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ISO-THES/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ISO-THES","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[\"Todo: \\nNot modelled but requiring further extension:\\n\\n- CustomTermAttribute : \\n  Best practice would be to define custom RDF data-type properties taking plain literal values. The property name depends on the customAttributeType.\\n\\n- CustomConceptAttribute :\\n  Best practice would be to define custom RDF data-type properties taking plain literal values. The property name depends on the customAttributeType.\\n\\n- refersTo (reference from within a note to a concept or label/term:\\n   May be an embedded and tagged link in the note value (e.g., as done for EuroVoc http://eurovoc.europa.eu/).\\n\\n- CustomNote :\\n  Depending noteType a new custom property should be defined as a sub-property of skos:note (consider applicability of: skos:changeNote and skos:example)\\n \\n - BTG/NTG - BTP/NTP - BTI/NTI :\\n   Currently these are only defined as direct (one-step) sub-properties of skos:broader / skos:narrower.\\n\\nSome constraints currently expressed only in natural language (in rdfs:comment) may be formally expressed as OWL(2) axioms.\\n\\nWe have postponed the implementation of the iso-thes properties mentioned in the VersionHistory section of the mapping documentation.\"]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/iso25964/skos-thes","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/iso25964/skos-thes"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/, http://www.w3.org/2008/05/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://www.w3.org/2008/05/skos-xl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns, http://purl.org/vocommons/voaf]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/, http://www.w3.org/2008/05/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ISO-THES/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://www.w3.org/2008/05/skos-xl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Antoine Isaac\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8d38d640-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8d38d640-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Johan De Smedt\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e1ac46f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e1ac46f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Marcia Zeng\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d3aef090-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d3aef090-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Vladimir Alexiev\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ef397440-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ef397440-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ISO-THES/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-03-17"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/ISO"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.75,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1249},"ITSMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ontology.it/itsmo/v1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":8.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ITSMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://ontology.it/itsmo/v1#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"IT Service Management Ontology (ITSMO) provides the vocabulary for      annotating  resources related to IT Service Management. ITSMO tries to be consistent with 2011 ITIL glossary.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[]","dct:title":"IT Service Management Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ITSMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-12-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-06-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ITSMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ITSMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ITSMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2025-02-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ITSMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ITSMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ITSMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ITSMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ITSMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":16.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":62.0,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ontology.it/itsmo/v1","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ontology.it/itsmo/v1"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":0.0,"normalizedScore":0,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ITSMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":36,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Enrico Fagnoni\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/90637710-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/90637710-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"E-Artspace Labs\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bdd57b20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bdd57b20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.e-artspace.com\"}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ITSMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2.0.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":226.0,"normalizedScore":47,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":459},"IOL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/IOLite.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IOL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/IOLite.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An ontology of information objects, encodings and realizations, as a plugin to DOLCE-Ultralite","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"General & Upper\"]","dct:title":"Information Objects ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IOL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#UpperLevelOntology","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2010-02-09T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=IOL&q=","schema:comment":"[\"An ontology of information objects, encodings and realizations, as a plugin to DOLCE-Ultralite (reusing mainly the dul:expresses and dul:realizes relations from it). \\nSeveral patterns are contained inside this ontology:\\n- encodings of information entities\\n- kinds of realizations (gestural motions, depictions, digital, multimedia, speech, etc.)\\n- combinatorial relations between information objects\\n- relations between formal expressions and generalized expressions (lexicalizations, formalizations)\\n- relations between formal expressions and their assignments in formal semantics\\n- relations between information objects and schemata (data structures, KOS, etc.)\\n- authorship\\n- kinds of linguistic objects\\n- copies, reproductions, etc.\\n- cultural combination of information objects (reuse, mixing, metaphorical blending)\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IOL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IOL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IOL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=IOL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/it]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IOL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IOL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IOL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/IOLite.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/IOLite.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IOL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IOL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.8"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.75,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":431},"INFOR":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/cp/owl/informationrealization.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"INFOR","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/cp/owl/informationrealization.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Allows designers to model information objects and their realizations. This allows to reason about physical objects and the information they realize, by keeping them distinguished.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Support\"]","dct:title":"Information Realization","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/INFOR/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2011-01-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=INFOR&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/INFOR/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/INFOR/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/INFOR/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=INFOR&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/INFOR/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/INFOR/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/INFOR","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/cp/owl/informationrealization.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/cp/owl/informationrealization.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/cpannotationschema.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/INFOR/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Valentina Presutti\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/da6109b0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/da6109b0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Aldo Gangemi\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0f70b2f0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0f70b2f0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/INFOR/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":251.75,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":443},"CAL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2002/12/cal/ical"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":16.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.w3.org/TR/rdfcal/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"CAL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/2002/12/cal/ical#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://esw.w3.org/topic/RdfCalendar","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A vocabulary for description of events and calendars","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Time\"]","dct:title":"Internet Calendaring and Scheduling Core Object Specification","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"W3C\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"W3C\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.w3.org/data#W3C\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CAL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-01-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CAL&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CAL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CAL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CAL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=CAL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CAL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CAL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CAL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":24.0,"normalizedScore":88,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":70.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2002/12/cal/ical","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/2002/12/cal/ical"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/12/cal/icalSpec#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CAL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Libby Miller\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c7e96860-da6c-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c7e96860-da6c-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dan Connolly\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fb167a20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fb167a20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/CAL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-01-11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/W3C"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":376},"LMM1":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/LMM_L1.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"LMM1","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/LMM_L1.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This ontology is a composition of some content design patterns for the semiotic triangle. Its structure is extracted from DOLCE-Ultralite (DOLCE+c.DnS), but it uses a different terminology,","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Vocabularies\"]","dct:title":"Lexical MetaModel Level 1","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM1/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2010-02-09T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=LMM1&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is a composition of some content design patterns for the semiotic triangle.\\nIts structure is extracted from DOLCE-Ultralite (DOLCE+c.DnS), but it uses a different terminology, and explicitly defines the semiotic function: Expression is the semiotic term for dul:InformationObject, when they actually express or denote something; Meaning is the semiotic term for dul:SocialObject, when they are actually expressed by something, or are interpretation of something; Reference is the semiotic term for dul:Entity, when they are interpreted or denoted by something.\\nThe denotes relation is equivalent to dul:isAbout, the expresses relation is imported from DOLCE Ultralite, and the hasInterpretation relation generalizes over: dul:isClassifiedBy, dul:isCoveredBy, dul:isDescribedBy, dul:isUnifiedBy, and dul:satisfies\\n\\nExtensions to the triangle:\\nA typical extension of the semiotic triangle concerns the participation of agents: this is introduced by using the dul:conceptualizes relation, holding between a dul:Agent and a dul:SocialObject (the Meaning). \\nAn additional extension concerns semiotic context: this is provided by including four notions of 'Context': 'Paradigm' (the context of the conceptualized meaning), 'KnowledgeCollective' (the context of agents that conceptualize the paradigm), 'Cotext' (the context of expressions), and dul:Situation (the context of denoted entities).\\nA final extension links semiotics to formal semantics: this is provided by reusing dul:FormalEntity, iol:isGroundingFor, iol:FormalExpression, iol:isAssignedTo, iol:FormalLanguage, etc.\\n\\nThe complete pattern allows to declare relations between Expression(s) and their Reference(s) (denotes), between Expression(s) and their Meaning (dul:expresses), between Meaning(s) and Reference(s) (isInterpretationOf), between Reference(s) and dul:FormalEntity(ies) (iol:isGroundingFor), between dul:FormalEntity(ies) and iol:FormalExpression(s) (iol:isAssignedTo).\\n\\nThis 'formalization pathway' moves from Expression(s) to iol:FormalExpression(s) by taking into account both Meaning(s) and Referent(s). The informal denotation of Expression(s) is moved to a formal denotation (iol:isAssignedTo) of iol:FormalExpression(s).\\nFor example: the Expression 'Mariachi' dul:expresses the dul:Concept (Meaning) 'MexicanStreetSinger' that isInterpretationOf the dul:Collection (Reference) 'TheStreetSingersFromMexico'. 'TheStreetSingersFromMexico' then iol:isGroundingFor e.g. the dul:Set (dul:FormalEntity) that includes all Mexican street singers, which iol:isAssignedTo e.g. the iol:FormalExpression 'owl:Class#Mariachi'.\\n\\nThe formalization pathway enables a technique to move from/to socio-cognitive and formal semantics through denotation, in the Tarskian sense. As a matter of fact, translating directly a Meaning into a FormalEntity (or viceversa) is not always clearly implementable, while passing through an extensional grounding is easier and more accessible to intuition.\\n\\nAmong possible uses, information extraction, ontology learning, KOS reengineering, lexical semantics, etc. For example, statistical learning of instances for a dul:Concept would be modelled as the building of a dul:Collection that isInterpretationOf the dul:Concept, but also dul:isGroundingFor a dul:Set that iol:isAssignedTo e.g. an owl:Class.\\n\\nAn additional semiotic pattern is based on the hasInterpretant relation, which allows to link two Expression(s) (or dul:InformationRealization(s)), when the second one counts as a Meaning (or a relatedMeaning) of the first. \\nIn practice, this is implemented by allowing a relation between an Expression (or its realization), and whatever Meaning (or another dul:InformationRealization). Technically speaking, the correct path would be passing through another Expression used to express a Meaning for the first one:\\n\\n(Exp1 hasInterpretant some (Exp2 and expresses some (Meaning and isExpressedBy some Exp1)))\\n\\nor even:\\n\\n(Exp1 hasInterpretant some (Exp2 and expresses some (Meaning and relatedMeaning some (Meaning and isExpressedBy some Exp1))))\\n\\nbut given the expressive power of OWL, which lacks co-reference, this is the best sub-optimal solution.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM1/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM1/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM1/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=LMM1&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/it]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM1/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM1/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM1","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/LMM_L1.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/LMM_L1.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl\"]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/IOLite.owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":20.75,"normalizedScore":64,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM1/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/IOLite.owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl\"]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":60.75,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Aldo Gangemi\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0f70b2f0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0f70b2f0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM1/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.8"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":261.75,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":468},"LMM2":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/LMM_L2.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"LMM2","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/LMM_L2.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An ontology for aligning existing linguistic ontologies, and for describing the research objects of NLP.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Vocabularies\"]","dct:title":"Lexical MetaModel Level 2","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM2/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2010-02-09T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=LMM2&q=","schema:comment":"[\"An ontology for aligning existing linguistic ontologies, and for describing the research objects of NLP.\\nIt uses the ontology IOLite.owl, a plugin of DOLCE-Ultralite for information objects; it imports LMM_L1.owl, a design pattern for the basic semiotic categories.\\nThe ontology also includes a proposal to match term types to referenced entity types, as an example of the usage of this ontology in NER and sense tagging applications.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM2/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM2/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM2/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=LMM2&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM2/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM2/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM2","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/LMM_L2.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/LMM_L2.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/LMM_L1.owl, http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/IOLite.owl, http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/LMM_L1.owl\",\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/IOLite.owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/LMM_L1.owl, http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/IOLite.owl, http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM2/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/lmm/LMM_L1.owl\",\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/IOLite.owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/ont/dul/DUL.owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Aldo Gangemi\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0f70b2f0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0f70b2f0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LMM2/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":256.75,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":439},"LIB":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/library/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"LIB","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/library/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Experimental \"library\" extension vocabulary for use with Schema.org","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Catalogs\"]","dct:title":"Library extension of schema.org","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LIB/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-06-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=LIB&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LIB/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LIB/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LIB/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=LIB&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LIB/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LIB/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LIB","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/library/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/library/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://schema.org/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://schema.org/CreativeWork/Book/, http://schema.org/CreativeWork/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://schema.org/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://schema.org/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LIB/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://schema.org/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://schema.org/CreativeWork/Book/, http://schema.org/CreativeWork/]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"OCLC Research\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d90cd800-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d90cd800-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://viaf.org/viaf/136069274\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/LIB/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2012-06-18"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":250.75,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1220},"MREL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://id.loc.gov/vocabulary/relators"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MREL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://id.loc.gov/vocabulary/relators/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"MARC relators are defined as both RDF properties and SKOS concepts","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Vocabularies\"]","dct:title":"MARC Code List for Relators","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Library of Congress\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/eb504480-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/eb504480-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Library_of_Congress\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MREL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2014-06-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MREL&q=","schema:comment":"[\"\\n\\t\\t\\n<xhtml:div class=\\\"relatorsAbout\\\" title=\\\"About the Relator Codes:\\\" datatype=\\\"rdf:XMLLiteral\\\" property=\\\"rdfs:comment\\\" xmlns:rdf=\\\"http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#\\\" xmlns:madsrdf=\\\"http://www.loc.gov/mads/rdf/v1#\\\" xmlns:xhtml=\\\"http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml\\\" xmlns:rdfs=\\\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\\\">\\n\\t\\t\\t<xhtml:p>\\n\\t\\t\\t\\tRelator terms and their associated codes designate the relationship between a name and a \\n                bibliographic resource. The relator codes are three-character lowercase alphabetic strings \\n                that serve as identifiers. Either the term or the code may be used as controlled values.\\n\\t\\t\\t<\\/xhtml:p>\\n\\t\\t<\\/xhtml:div>\\n\\n\\t\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MREL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MREL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MREL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MREL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MREL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MREL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MREL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://id.loc.gov/vocabulary/relators","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://id.loc.gov/vocabulary/relators"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.loc.gov/mads/rdf/v1, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.75,"normalizedScore":17,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MREL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.75,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MREL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2014-06-03"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":230.75,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":422},"MARL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.gsi.dit.upm.es/ontologies/marl/ns"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.gsi.dit.upm.es/ontologies/marl/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MARL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.gsi.dit.upm.es/ontologies/marl/ns#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Marl is a standardised data schema designed to annotate and describe subjective opinions expressed on the web or in particular Information Systems.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Support\"]","dct:title":"Marl Ontology Specification","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MARL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2013-05-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MARL&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MARL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MARL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MARL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MARL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MARL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MARL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MARL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.gsi.dit.upm.es/ontologies/marl/ns","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.gsi.dit.upm.es/ontologies/marl/ns"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov-o#","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MARL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"J. Fernando Sánchez-Rada\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/aad5eec0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/aad5eec0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Adam Westerski\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ed0ce3c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ed0ce3c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MARL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":243.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":247},"MVCO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.oclc.org/NET/mvco.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://dmag.ac.upc.edu/ontologies/mvco/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MVCO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.oclc.org/NET/mvco.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Media Value Chain Ontology (MVCO) is an ontology for formalizing the representation of the Media Value Chain. It couples naturally with the MPEG-21 multimedia framework, and its standardization as Part 19 of this ISO/IEC standard is underway (at the editing time of this document).","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Multimedia\"]","dct:title":"Media Value Chain Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Distributed Multimedia Applications Group\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/be073820-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/be073820-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dmag.ac.upc.edu/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MVCO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2010-05-07T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MVCO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"ISO/IEC 21000-19 Media Value Chain Ontology (MVCO)\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MVCO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MVCO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MVCO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MVCO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MVCO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MVCO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MVCO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.oclc.org/NET/mvco.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.oclc.org/NET/mvco.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[urn:mpeg:mpeg21:2002:01-DII-NS#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[urn:mpeg:mpeg21:2002:01-DII-NS#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MVCO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MVCO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/IEC"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":246.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1407},"MADS":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.loc.gov/mads/rdf/v1"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.loc.gov/standards/mads/rdf/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MADS","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.loc.gov/mads/rdf/v1#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"MADS/RDF (Metadata Authority Description Schema in RDF) is a knowledge organization system (KOS) designed for use with controlled values for names (personal, corporate, geographic, etc.), thesauri, taxonomies, subject heading systems, and other controlled value lists","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"Metadata Authority Description Schema","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Library of Congress\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/eb504480-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/eb504480-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Library_of_Congress\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MADS/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-10-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MADS&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Updated: 10 May 2012 - Added Language Class; componentList and\\n      elementList now has the union of rdf:List or rdf:Seq for a range.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MADS/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MADS/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MADS/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MADS&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MADS/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MADS/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MADS","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.loc.gov/mads/rdf/v1","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.loc.gov/mads/rdf/v1"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://www.w3.org/2008/05/skos-xl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MADS/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\",\"http://www.w3.org/2008/05/skos-xl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MADS/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-1028"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":242.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1101},"MUSIC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.kanzaki.com/ns/music"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MUSIC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.kanzaki.com/ns/music#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A vocabulary, or music ontology, to describe classical music and performances. Classes (categories) for musical works, events, instruments and performers, as well as related properties are defined. Make sure to distinguish musical works (e.g. Opera) from performance events (Opera_Event), or works (String_Quartette) from performer (StringQuartetEnsemble in this vocab), whose natural language terms are used interchangeblly. The present version experiments more precise model to describe a musical work, its representations (performances, scores, etc) and a musical event to present a representation (a concert). Includes 30 keys as individuals.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Events\"]","dct:title":"Music Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MUSIC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2007-10-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MUSIC&q=","schema:comment":"[\"A vocabulary, or music ontology, to describe classical music and performances. Classes (categories) for musical works, events, instruments and performers, as well as related properties are defined. Make sure to distinguish musical works (e.g. Opera) from performance events (Opera_Event), or works (String_Quartette) from performer (StringQuartetEnsemble in this vocab), whose natural language terms are used interchangeblly. The present version experiments more precise model to describe a musical work, its representations (performances, scores, etc) and a musical event to present a representation (a concert). Includes 30 keys as individuals.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MUSIC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MUSIC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MUSIC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MUSIC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/ja","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MUSIC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MUSIC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MUSIC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.kanzaki.com/ns/music","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/xml, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.kanzaki.com/ns/music"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.kanzaki.com/ns/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://purl.org/net/ns/ontology-annot, http://purl.org/net/ns/ex]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.kanzaki.com/ns/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MUSIC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Masahide Kanzaki\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c96d1b80-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c96d1b80-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MUSIC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.96"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.75,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2128},"NIF":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://persistence.uni-leipzig.org/nlp2rdf/ontologies/nif-core#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NIF","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://persistence.uni-leipzig.org/nlp2rdf/ontologies/nif-core#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The NLP Interchange Format (NIF) is an RDF/OWL-based format that aims to achieve interoperability between Natural Language Processing (NLP) tools, language resources and annotations.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Vocabularies\"]","dct:title":"NLP Interchange Format","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Agile Knowledge Engineering and Semantic Web\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d2e90020-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d2e90020-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://aksw.org/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"nif","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NIF/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-01-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=NIF&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The NLP Interchange Format (NIF) is an RDF/OWL-based format that aims to achieve interoperability between Natural Language Processing (NLP) tools, language resources and annotations. NIF consists of specifications, ontologies and software, which are combined under the version identifier \\\"2.0\\\", but are versioned individually. This ontology is developed by the NLP2RDF project (http://nlp2rdf.org) and provided as part of NIF 2.0 under CC-BY license as well as Apache 2.0. The ontology contains seven core URIs (String, RFC5147String, Context, isString, referenceContext, beginIndex, endIndex) that provide the foundation  to express NLP annotations effectively in RDF.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NIF/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NIF/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NIF/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=NIF&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NIF/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NIF/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NIF","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://persistence.uni-leipzig.org/nlp2rdf/ontologies/nif-core#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://persistence.uni-leipzig.org/nlp2rdf/ontologies/nif-core#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://lexvo.org/ontology, http://purl.org/marl/ns#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://lexvo.org/ontology, http://purl.org/marl/ns#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NIF/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sebastian Hellmann\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/7c874c40-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/7c874c40-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NIF/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-01-11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":247.44,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":960},"NLON":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://lod.nl.go.kr/ontology/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"NLON","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://lod.nl.go.kr/ontology/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This specification describes National Library of Korea Ontology vocaburaries using W3C's RDF and OWL technology.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Catalogs\"]","dct:title":"National Library of Korea Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Library of Korea\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/05008ce0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/05008ce0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://lod.nl.go.kr/library/011001\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"nlon","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NLON/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-11-23T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=NLON&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This specification describes National Library of Korea Ontology vocaburaries using W3C's RDF and OWL technology.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NLON/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NLON/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2015-11-23T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NLON/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=NLON&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/ko]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NLON/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NLON/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NLON","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://lod.nl.go.kr/ontology/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://lod.nl.go.kr/ontology/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/dc/dcam/, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/, http://purl.org/dc/dcmitype/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2003/01/geo/wgs84_pos\",\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns, http://creativecommons.org/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.44,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/dc/dcam/, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/, http://purl.org/dc/dcmitype/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NLON/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2003/01/geo/wgs84_pos\",\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.44,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Wonseok\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a347a600-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a347a600-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"wonseok.oh@li-st.com\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"JoyHong\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ec4996e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ec4996e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"joyhong@li-st.com\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"LiST Inc\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f56e0490-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f56e0490-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://listinc.kr/id/listinc\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"National Library of Korea\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/05008ce0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/05008ce0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://lod.nl.go.kr/library/011001\"}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/NLON/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-11-23"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":47.0,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":261.44,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1981},"GML":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.opengis.net/ont/gml"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"GML","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.opengis.net/ont/gml#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A specialization of GeoSPARQL defining specific subtypes of Geometry","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Geometry\"]","dct:title":"OGC Geometry","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GML/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-09-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=GML&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GML/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GML/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GML/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=GML&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GML/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GML/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GML","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.opengis.net/ont/gml","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.opengis.net/ont/gml"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.opengis.net/ont/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.opengis.net/ont/geosparql\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.opengis.net/ont/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GML/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.opengis.net/ont/geosparql\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Open Geospatial Consortium\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/baf1fd60-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/baf1fd60-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Open_Geospatial_Consortium\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GML/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.01"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":559},"OML":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/om-lite"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OML","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/om-lite#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://www.semantic-web-journal.net/content/ontology-observations-and-sampling-features-alignments-existing-models-0","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An OWL representation of the Observation Schema described in clauses 7-8 of ISO 19156:2011 Geographic Information - Observations and Measurements / OGC Abstract Specification - Topic 20.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Geography\"]","dct:title":"OWL for Observations","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"oml:","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OML/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2016-01-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=OML&q=","schema:comment":"[\"An OWL representation of the Observation Schema described in clauses 7-8 of ISO 19156:2011 Geographic Information - Observations and Measurements. \\nIn contrast to previous versions developed through SSN and in conjunction with ISO 19150-2, this ontology has minimal dependencies on existing ontologies, particularly those that trigger extended chains of imports. Stub classes are provided for time, geometry and measure (scaled number), which can be substituted at run-time by a suitable concrete representation of the concept. \\nObservation Collection has been (re-)introduced, to support the common case where a collection is homogeneous in one or more properties (feature-of-interest, phenomenon-time, observed-property, units-of-measure, procedure). The value of the common property may be recorded against the collection instead of repetitively against every member.   \\n\\nIn this revision, the observation result is an Object Property, in order to conform to strict OWL2 semantics. The type constraints on Observation specializations TruthObservation and CountObservation have been changed, so that the range of oml:result is an Object containing the xsd type, rather than the data-type itself. \"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OML/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OML/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2016-01-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OML/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=OML&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fr]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OML/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OML/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OML","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/om-lite","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/om-lite"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.44,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OML/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/isotc211/iso19156/2011/observation","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/au/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.44,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/au/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-3884-3420\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-3884-3420\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Simon J D Cox\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d6071460-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d6071460-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OML/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/isotc211/iso19156/2011/observation","owl:versionInfo":"v2016-01-20"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":259.44,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":435},"SAMFL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SAMFL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A simple OWL representation of the Sampling Features Schema described in clauses 9-11 of ISO 19156:2011 Geographic Information - Observations and Measurements","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Geography\"]","dct:title":"OWL for Sampling Features","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"saml:","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SAMFL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Curve\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Elevation\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#GeometryObject\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Location\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Measure\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#ObservationProcess\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Point\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Process\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingCollection\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingCurve\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingFeature\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingFeatureComplex\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingPoint\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingSolid\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingSurface\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Solid\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SpatialSamplingFeature\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Specimen\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Surface\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#complex\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#currentLocation\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#elevation\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#hostedProcedure\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#materialClass\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#relatedSamplingFeature\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#role\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#sampledFeature\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#samplingElevation\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#samplingLocation\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#samplingMethod\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#samplingTime\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#shape\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#size\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#verticalDatum\"]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-11-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SAMFL&q=","schema:comment":"[\"An OWL representation of the Sampling Features Schema described in clauses 9-11 of ISO 19156:2011 Geographic Information - Observations and Measurements. \\nIn contrast to previous versions developed through SSN and in conjunction with ISO 19150-2, this ontology has minimal dependencies on existing ontologies, particularly those that trigger extended chains of imports. Stub classes are provided for time, geometry and measure (scaled number), which can be substituted at run-time by a suitable concrete representation of the concept. \\nThe model for Specimen has a dependency on W3C PROV-O. Specimen is modelled as a subclass of prov:Entity, so PROV can be used to describe specimen preparation chains. \"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SAMFL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SAMFL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2015-11-17T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SAMFL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SAMFL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SAMFL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SAMFL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SAMFL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":65.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/ns/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/om-lite"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":20.44,"normalizedScore":63,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Curve\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Elevation\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#GeometryObject\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Location\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Measure\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#ObservationProcess\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Point\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Process\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingCollection\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingCurve\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingFeature\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingFeatureComplex\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingPoint\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingSolid\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SamplingSurface\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Solid\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#SpatialSamplingFeature\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Specimen\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#Surface\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#complex\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#currentLocation\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#elevation\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#hostedProcedure\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#materialClass\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#relatedSamplingFeature\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#role\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#sampledFeature\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#samplingElevation\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#samplingLocation\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#samplingMethod\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#samplingTime\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#shape\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#size\",\"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/sam-lite#verticalDatum\"]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/ns/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SAMFL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/isotc211/iso19156/2011/sampling","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/au/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/ontology/om/om-lite","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":60.44,"normalizedScore":55,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/au/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0002-3884-3420\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0002-3884-3420\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Simon J D Cox\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d6071460-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d6071460-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SAMFL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"http://def.seegrid.csiro.au/isotc211/iso19156/2011/sampling","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-11-17"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":262.44,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":816},"OC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://contextus.net/ontology/ontomedia/core/expression#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://contextus.net/ontology/ontomedia/core/expression#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"OntoMedia (Ontology for Media) has been designed to describe the interactions occurring in multimedia.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Multimedia\"]","dct:title":"OntoMedia Core","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2005-05-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=OC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=OC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://contextus.net/ontology/ontomedia/core/expression#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://contextus.net/ontology/ontomedia/core/expression#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://contextus.net/ontology/ontomedia/misc/locspec#, http://contextus.net/ontology/ontomedia/core/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://contextus.net/ontology/ontomedia/misc/date#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://contextus.net/ontology/ontomedia/misc/locspec#, http://contextus.net/ontology/ontomedia/core/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://contextus.net/ontology/ontomedia/misc/date#]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Michael O. Jewell\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9a154350-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9a154350-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"moj@ecs.soton.ac.uk\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"K Faith Lawrence\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b76f1f30-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b76f1f30-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"kf03r@ecs.soton.ac.uk\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Mischa M Tuffield\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cca96820-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cca96820-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"mmt04r@ecs.soton.ac.uk\",\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.32"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":236.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":459},"MA-ONT":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/ma-ont"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.w3.org/TR/mediaont-10/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"MA-ONT","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/ns/ma-ont#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Ontology for Media Resources 1.0 describes a core vocabulary of properties and a set of mappings between different metadata formats of media resources hat describe media resources published on the Web (as opposed to local archives, museums, or other non-web related and non-shared collections of media resources).","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Multimedia\"]","dct:title":"Ontology for Media Resources","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"W3C\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"W3C\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0cd0ef40-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.w3.org/data#W3C\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MA-ONT/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2013-03-20T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MA-ONT&q=","schema:comment":"[\"THE CONTENT OF THIS MA-ONT.RDF AND DERIVED MA-ONT.TTL FILES PREVAIL OVER THE SPECIFICATION.\",\"Created by Tobias Buerger, Jean Pierre Evain and Pierre-Antoine Champin with the RDFS Taskforce within the W3C Media Annotation Working Group.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MA-ONT/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MA-ONT/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MA-ONT/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=MA-ONT&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MA-ONT/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MA-ONT/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MA-ONT","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/ma-ont","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/ma-ont"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://dublincore.org/2008/01/14/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://dublincore.org/2008/01/14/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MA-ONT/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jean-Pierre Evain\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/107b39c0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/107b39c0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/MA-ONT/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0-R36"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/W3C"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":369},"GEOM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.ign.fr/def/geometrie"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"GEOM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://data.ign.fr/def/geometrie#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An ontology for describing the shape and the location of topographic entities","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Geometry\"]","dct:title":"Ontology for geometry","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"IGN\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institut National de l'Information Géographique et Forestière\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e4ac5de0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e4ac5de0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://fr.dbpedia.org/resource/Institut_national_de_l%27information_g%C3%A9ographique_et_foresti%C3%A8re\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"geom","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-01-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=GEOM&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2014-08-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=GEOM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fr]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.ign.fr/def/geometrie","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.ign.fr/def/geometrie"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://data.ign.fr/def/ignf, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.opengis.net/ont/sf\",\"http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://geovocab.org/geometry\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://creativecommons.org/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.33,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://data.ign.fr/def/ignf, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.opengis.net/ont/sf\",\"http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://geovocab.org/geometry\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://www.data.gouv.fr/Licence-Ouverte-Open-Licence","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.33,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://www.data.gouv.fr/Licence-Ouverte-Open-Licence"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Nathalie Abadie\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8aac9700-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8aac9700-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-1562-6922\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-1562-6922\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ghislain Atemezing\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d3de2660-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d3de2660-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-0457-1436\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-0457-1436\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Raphaël Troncy\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8e21f770-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8e21f770-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bernard Vatant\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d5589210-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d5589210-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Bénédicte Bucher\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ee0e4490-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ee0e4490-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/GEOM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-01-11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":40.0,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.33,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":523},"TURISMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://idi.fundacionctic.org/cruzar/turismo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"TURISMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://idi.fundacionctic.org/cruzar/turismo#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The ontology is applied to an application to compute the touristic paths in the city of Saragossa.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Travel\"]","dct:title":"Ontology of Tourist for Saragossa town hall.","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TURISMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2007-11-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=TURISMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TURISMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TURISMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TURISMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=TURISMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/de, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/es, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fr, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/it, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/pt]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TURISMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TURISMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TURISMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://idi.fundacionctic.org/cruzar/turismo","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://idi.fundacionctic.org/cruzar/turismo"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2003/01/geo/wgs84_pos, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/ExtendedDnS#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/DOLCE-Lite#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/CommonSenseMapping#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/TemporalRelations#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/SpatialRelations#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/FunctionalParticipation#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/ExtendedDnS#\",\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/DOLCE-Lite#\",\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/CommonSenseMapping#\",\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/Collectives#\",\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/Plans#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/ExtendedDnS#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/DOLCE-Lite#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/CommonSenseMapping#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/TemporalRelations#, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2003/01/geo/wgs84_pos, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/ExtendedDnS#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/DOLCE-Lite#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/CommonSenseMapping#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/TemporalRelations#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/SpatialRelations#, http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/FunctionalParticipation#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TURISMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/ExtendedDnS#\",\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/DOLCE-Lite#\",\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/CommonSenseMapping#\",\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/Collectives#\",\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/Plans#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CTIC\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"CTIC Foundation\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0164e170-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0164e170-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://data.semanticweb.org/organization/fundacion-ctic\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/TURISMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":236.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":249},"IDENTITY":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.identity.org/ontologies/identity.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"IDENTITY","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.identity.org/ontologies/identity.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"v.2.0 based on P3P1.0 Specification http://www.w3.org/TR/P3P/","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Security\"]","dct:title":"Ontology of digital identity.","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDENTITY/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2014-04-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=IDENTITY&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Ontology of digital identity.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDENTITY/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDENTITY/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDENTITY/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=IDENTITY&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fr]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDENTITY/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDENTITY/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDENTITY","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.identity.org/ontologies/identity.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.identity.org/ontologies/identity.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDENTITY/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Johann Vincent\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bb32f8c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bb32f8c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/IDENTITY/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2014-04-03"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":236.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":4762},"OPMO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://openprovenance.org/model/opmo"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"OPMO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://openprovenance.org/model/opmo#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"Used","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Open Provenance Model is a model of provenance that is designed to meet the following requirements: (1) To allow provenance information to be exchanged between systems, by means of a compatibility layer based on a shared provenance model. (2) To allow developers to build and share tools that operate on such a provenance model. (3) To define provenance in a precise, technology-agnostic manner. (4) To support a digital representation of provenance for any 'thing', whether produced by computer systems or not. (5) To allow multiple levels of description to coexist. (6) To define a core set of rules that identify the valid inferences that can be made on provenance representation.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Quality\"]","dct:title":"Open Provenance Model","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OPMO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2010-10-12T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=OPMO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OPMO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OPMO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2015-01-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OPMO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=OPMO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OPMO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OPMO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OPMO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://openprovenance.org/model/opmo","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://openprovenance.org/model/opmo"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://purl.org/net/opmv/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema, http://purl.org/net/opmv/ns#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://purl.org/net/opmv/ns#\"]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://vocab.deri.ie/void, http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://purl.org/net/opmv/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema, http://purl.org/net/opmv/ns#]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OPMO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://purl.org/net/opmv/ns#\"]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Michael O. Jewell\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9a154350-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9a154350-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":\"moj@ecs.soton.ac.uk\",\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jun Zhao\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/aa5e54e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/aa5e54e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Joe Futrelle\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bab64b20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bab64b20-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Daniel Garijo\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c5fd6650-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c5fd6650-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jeff Pan\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d35bef60-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/d35bef60-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Li Ding\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ea964cc0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ea964cc0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Luc Moreau\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fd6f49d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fd6f49d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paolo Missier\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ff8aad40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ff8aad40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Simon Miles\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/01e42420-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/01e42420-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paul Groth\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0333af80-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0333af80-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/OPMO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-01-11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":243.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":485},"PMLP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://inference-web.org/2.0/pml-provenance.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PMLP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://inference-web.org/2.0/pml-provenance.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The provenance part of PML2 ontology. It is a fundamental component of PML2 ontology.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Quality\"]","dct:title":"PML2 provenance ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PMLP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-01-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PMLP&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The provenance part of PML2 ontology. It is a fundamental component of PML2 ontology.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PMLP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PMLP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PMLP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PMLP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PMLP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PMLP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PMLP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://inference-web.org/2.0/pml-provenance.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://inference-web.org/2.0/pml-provenance.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://inference-web.org/2.0/ds.owl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://inference-web.org/2.0/ds.owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://inference-web.org/2.0/ds.owl","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PMLP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://inference-web.org/2.0/ds.owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cynthia Chang\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/91c2ee60-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/91c2ee60-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0001-7037-4567\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0001-7037-4567\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Deborah L. McGuinness\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf788f50-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf788f50-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Li Ding\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ea964cc0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ea964cc0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Alyssa Glass\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/1181c690-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/1181c690-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paulo Pinheiro da Silva\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/11f28e90-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/11f28e90-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PMLP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"version 2.0, Authors: Deborah L. McGuinness, Li Ding, Paulo Pinheiro da Silva, Alyssa Glass, and Cynthia Chang"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":241.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":575},"PTOP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontotext.com/proton/protontop"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.ontotext.com/proton-ontology","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PTOP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.ontotext.com/proton/protontop#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The PROTON Top module represents the most general classes","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"PROTON\"]","dct:title":"PROTON (Proto Ontology), Top Module","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ontotext\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9adac1f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9adac1f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Ontotext\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PTOP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-02-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PTOP&q=","schema:comment":"[\"PROTON (Proto Ontology), Top module\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PTOP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PTOP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PTOP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PTOP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PTOP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PTOP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PTOP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontotext.com/proton/protontop","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontotext.com/proton/protontop"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PTOP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Ontotext\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9adac1f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9adac1f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/Ontotext\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PTOP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v3.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1104},"PLO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/net/po#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PLO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/net/po#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An ontology for describing playlists, playlist entries and songs.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Music\"]","dct:title":"Playlist Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"po","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PLO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2014-08-26T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PLO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PLO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PLO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PLO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PLO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PLO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PLO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PLO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":65.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/net/po#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/net/po#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/ontology/mo/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.33,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://purl.org/ontology/mo/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PLO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.33,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Milos Jovanovik\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b9808260-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b9808260-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PLO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2014-08-26"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":246.33,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1211},"PROVOC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ns.inria.fr/provoc"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PROVOC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://ns.inria.fr/provoc#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"ProVoc (Product Vocabulary) is a vocabulary that can be used to represent information and manipulate them through the Web. This ontology reflects: 1) The basic hierarchy of a company: Group (Company), Divisions of a Group, Brand names attached to a Division or a Group, and 2) The production of a company: products, ranges of products (attached to a Brand), the composition of a product, packages of products...","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"eBusiness\"]","dct:title":"Product Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Institut National de Recherche en Informatique et en Automatique\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/99b0a5f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/99b0a5f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/National_Institute_for_Research_in_Computer_Science_and_Control\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"INRIA\",\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ROR\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"02kvxyf05\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ROR:02kvxyf05\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"INRIA\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c69d09c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c69d09c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://dbpedia.org/resource/National_Institute_for_Research_in_Computer_Science_and_Control\"},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Viseo\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fb5cd650-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fb5cd650-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.viseo.com/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PROVOC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2016-02-18T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PROVOC&q=","schema:comment":"[\"ProVoc (Product Vocabulary) is a vocabulary that can be used to represent information and manipulate them through the Web. This ontology reflects: 1) The basic hierarchy of a company: Group (Company), Divisions of a Group, Brand names attached to a Division or a Group, and 2) The production of a company: products, ranges of products (attached to a Brand), the composition of a product, packages of products...\\n\\n\\nWhat contributions ? \\n\\n- pv:Range\\nIn ProVoc we introduce pv:Range.\\nGoodRelations defined \\\"variants\\\" ( http://wiki.goodrelations-vocabulary.org/Documentation/Product_variants , http://www.heppnetz.de/ontologies/goodrelations/v1.html#isVariantOf ) as following: \\\"\\\"A variant is a specialization of a product model and inherits all of its product properties, unless they are defined locally. This allows a very compact modeling of product models that vary only in  a few properties. \\\"\\nAccording to GoodRelations, a variant of a MacBook is for example a MacBook13Inch or MacBook15Inch which vary in screen size and in available USB ports. This is inheritage between a product model and its derivatives, which must meet the standards imposed by the product model (obviously values can be redefined locally). According to the current version of GoodRelations,gr:isVariantOf necessarily exists between two models of product or service. However, ranges of products can hardly be considered as a set of derivatives of a product (or model of product). For example, Elsève is a range of products offering shampoos with some derivatives, but Elsève also offers creams with derivatives, oils with derivatives etc., so apart that such products are related to treatment for hair, they have not much in common. Using gr:isVariantOf between certain 'close' products, we would obtain multiple clusters of related products, to the detriment of a unique range of products. Using pv:Range allows to respect the structure provided by the expert.\\nIn conclusion, variants seem to identify similar products (see also http://www.heppnetz.de/ontologies/goodrelations/v1#isSimilarTo which differs from gr:isVariantOf by the fact that the domain and ranks of isSimilarTo are larger), but pv:range has a different vocation.\\ngr:isVariantOf has a very broad and subjective semantics (such as gr:isSimilarTo, as Mr. Hepp said clearly here http://www.heppnetz.de/ontologies/goodrelations/v1#isSimilarTo ). For example , with gr:isVariantOf it would be possible to express that a Renault Clio 4 is a variant of a Ford Fiesta ( http://www.autonews.fr/nouveautes/nouveaute/104216-renault-clio-fiesta-prix/ yet they are not of the same brand) whilst they are not of the same brand name.\\nFinally, note that a pv:Range does not represent a set of products nor product models. pv:range is used to objectively link a brand to its products (provided by the expert).\\nIt would be appropriate to limit the use of gr:isVariantOf to products belonging to a pv:Range.\\n\\n- pv:Package\\nIn ProVoc we introduce the pv:Package class that is used to represent sets of products sold as a single product. For example a cosmetic box containing a BB cream, a lip gloss, and a perfume byl Lancôme. Another example is a food package that contains different products.\\n\\n- pv:Provider\\nIn ProVoc we introduce the pv:Provider that makes a product available in the e-commerce.\\n\\n- pv:Component\\nIn ProVoc we introduce the pv:Component which enables to describe the composition of a product (for instance, a perfume can contain linalool).\\n\\nWe  introduce more properties and classes in order to refine the model. For instance, pv:Model, pv:Designer, and pv:Ambassador appear as a subclass of foaf:Person.  ProVoc can also be used in order to link products and their components with their impact on health ( see pv:healthImpact).\\n\\nConcerning classic properties related to the product, such as color, price, reference, description, etc., see Good Relations (http://www.heppnetz.de/projects/goodrelations/).\\n\",\"ProVoc (Product Vocabulary) is a vocabulary that can be used to represent information and manipulate them through the Web. This ontology reflects: 1) The basic hierarchy of a company: Group (Company), Divisions of a Group, Brand names attached to a Division or a Group, and 2) The production of a company: products, ranges of products (attached to a Brand), the composition of a product, packages of products...\\r\\n\\r\\n\\r\\nWhat contributions ? \\r\\n\\r\\n- pv:Range\\r\\nIn ProVoc we introduce pv:Range.\\r\\nGoodRelations defined \\\"variants\\\" ( http://wiki.goodrelations-vocabulary.org/Documentation/Product_variants , http://www.heppnetz.de/ontologies/goodrelations/v1.html#isVariantOf ) as following: \\\"\\\"A variant is a specialization of a product model and inherits all of its product properties, unless they are defined locally. This allows a very compact modeling of product models that vary only in  a few properties. \\\"\\r\\nAccording to GoodRelations, a variant of a MacBook is for example a MacBook13Inch or MacBook15Inch which vary in screen size and in available USB ports. This is inheritage between a product model and its derivatives, which must meet the standards imposed by the product model (obviously values can be redefined locally). According to the current version of GoodRelations,gr:isVariantOf necessarily exists between two models of product or service. However, ranges of products can hardly be considered as a set of derivatives of a product (or model of product). For example, Elsève is a range of products offering shampoos with some derivatives, but Elsève also offers creams with derivatives, oils with derivatives etc., so apart that such products are related to treatment for hair, they have not much in common. Using gr:isVariantOf between certain 'close' products, we would obtain multiple clusters of related products, to the detriment of a unique range of products. Using pv:Range allows to respect the structure provided by the expert.\\r\\nIn conclusion, variants seem to identify similar products (see also http://www.heppnetz.de/ontologies/goodrelations/v1#isSimilarTo which differs from gr:isVariantOf by the fact that the domain and ranks of isSimilarTo are larger), but pv:range has a different vocation.\\r\\ngr:isVariantOf has a very broad and subjective semantics (such as gr:isSimilarTo, as Mr. Hepp said clearly here http://www.heppnetz.de/ontologies/goodrelations/v1#isSimilarTo ). For example , with gr:isVariantOf it would be possible to express that a Renault Clio 4 is a variant of a Ford Fiesta ( http://www.autonews.fr/nouveautes/nouveaute/104216-renault-clio-fiesta-prix/ yet they are not of the same brand) whilst they are not of the same brand name.\\r\\nFinally, note that a pv:Range does not represent a set of products nor product models. pv:range is used to objectively link a brand to its products (provided by the expert).\\r\\nIt would be appropriate to limit the use of gr:isVariantOf to products belonging to a pv:Range.\\r\\n\\r\\n- pv:Package\\r\\nIn ProVoc we introduce the pv:Package class that is used to represent sets of products sold as a single product. For example a cosmetic box containing a BB cream, a lip gloss, and a perfume byl Lancôme. Another example is a food package that contains different products.\\r\\n\\r\\n- pv:Provider\\r\\nIn ProVoc we introduce the pv:Provider that makes a product available in the e-commerce.\\r\\n\\r\\n- pv:Component\\r\\nIn ProVoc we introduce the pv:Component which enables to describe the composition of a product (for instance, a perfume can contain linalool).\\r\\n\\r\\nWe  introduce more properties and classes in order to refine the model. For instance, pv:Model, pv:Designer, and pv:Ambassador appear as a subclass of foaf:Person.  ProVoc can also be used in order to link products and their components with their impact on health ( see pv:healthImpact).\\r\\n\\r\\nConcerning classic properties related to the product, such as color, price, reference, description, etc., see Good Relations (http://www.heppnetz.de/projects/goodrelations/).\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PROVOC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PROVOC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PROVOC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PROVOC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/fr]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PROVOC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PROVOC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PROVOC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ns.inria.fr/provoc","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://ns.inria.fr/provoc"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/org#, http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1, http://schema.org/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2006/vcard/ns, http://www.heppnetz.de/ontologies/goodrelations/v1#, http://vivoweb.org/ontology/core, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema, http://xmlns.com/foaf/spec/#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://creativecommons.org/ns, http://purl.org/vocommons/voaf]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/ns/org#, http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1, http://schema.org/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2006/vcard/ns, http://www.heppnetz.de/ontologies/goodrelations/v1#, http://vivoweb.org/ontology/core, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema, http://xmlns.com/foaf/spec/#]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PROVOC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Frederique Segond\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ab8cab00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/ab8cab00-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elena Cabrio\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bd191c70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bd191c70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Fabien Gandon\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f2d3cea0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f2d3cea0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Cedric Lopez\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/058cc920-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/058cc920-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PROVOC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.75,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":595},"RAUL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.deri.ie/raul"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://vocab.deri.ie/raul.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RAUL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/NET/raul#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A vocabulary to describe Web form widgets. Strongly aligned with the meta model of HTML Web forms. A RESTful service that can render HTML Web forms from RaUL models can be found at: http://w3c.org.au/raul","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"API\"]","dct:title":"RAUL Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"raul","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RAUL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2013-02-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RAUL&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RAUL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RAUL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2012-04-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RAUL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RAUL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RAUL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RAUL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RAUL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.deri.ie/raul","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.deri.ie/raul"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.5,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RAUL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.5,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[{\"schemaAgency\":\"ORCID\",\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"notation\":\"0000-0003-3425-0780\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Identifiers/ORCID:0000-0003-3425-0780\"}],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Armin Haller\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8dcd3a70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8dcd3a70-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jürgen Umbrich\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bfc490e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bfc490e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Michael Hausenblas\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fafd3600-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fafd3600-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RAUL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2013-02-22"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":239.5,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6379},"RDAA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/a"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/RDARegistry/RDA-Vocabularies/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDAA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/a/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Agent properties element set consists of properties representing the attributes and relationships of the RDA Agent, Person, Family, and Corporate Body entities. Each property in the element set has a domain of the class representing one of these entities.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"FRBR\"]","dct:title":"RDA Agent properties","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-12-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAA&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAA/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/a","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/a"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/i, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/c, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/e, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/m]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/rdakit/, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/RegAp/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/i, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/c, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/e, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/m]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Joint Steering Committee for Development of RDA\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc0b65d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc0b65d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.rda-jsc.org/\"}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gordon Dunsire\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f18135d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f18135d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2.4.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/RDA"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.75,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1021},"RDAC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/c"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/RDARegistry/RDA-Vocabularies/blob/master/ttl/Elements/c.ttl","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDAC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/c/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Classes element set consists of classes representing the RDA entities, including Work, Expression, Manifestation, Item, Person, Family, Corporate Body, and Agent.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"FRBR\"]","dct:title":"RDA Classes","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Joint Steering Committee for Development of RDA\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc0b65d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc0b65d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.rda-jsc.org/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-12-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/c","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/c"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/RegAp/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.75,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":43.75,"normalizedScore":40,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gordon Dunsire\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f18135d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f18135d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2.4.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/RDA"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":245.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1144},"RDAG1":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/Elements"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://dublincore.org/dcmirdataskgroup/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDAG1","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdvocab.info/Elements/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This is the provisional registration of the RDA Group 1 Element Vocabulary, managed by the DCMI/RDA Task Group.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"RDA Group 1 Elements","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG1/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-08-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAG1&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG1/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG1/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG1/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAG1&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG1/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG1/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG1","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/Elements","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/Elements"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://rdvocab.info/\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/RegAp/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG1/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://rdvocab.info/\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Metadata Management Associates\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf395bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf395bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://managemetadata.com/\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG1/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2012-08-30"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/RDA"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":244.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1834},"RDAG2":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/ElementsGr2"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDAG2","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdvocab.info/ElementsGr2/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The second group of metadata elements defined by RDA","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"RDA Group 2 Elements","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG2/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2011-10-13T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAG2&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG2/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG2/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG2/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAG2&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG2/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG2/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG2","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/ElementsGr2","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/ElementsGr2"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/RegAp/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.75,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG2/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.75,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Metadata Management Associates\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf395bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf395bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://managemetadata.com/\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG2/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2011-10-13"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/RDA"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1553},"RDAG3":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/ElementsGr3"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDAG3","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdvocab.info/ElementsGr3/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This group of RDA elements defines preferred and variant names for concepts, places and events","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"RDA Group 3 Elements","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG3/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2011-08-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAG3&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG3/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG3/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG3/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAG3&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG3/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG3/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG3","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/ElementsGr3","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/ElementsGr3"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/RegAp/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.75,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG3/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.75,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Metadata Management Associates\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf395bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf395bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://managemetadata.com/\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAG3/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2011-08-01"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/RDA"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1613},"RDAI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/i"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/RDARegistry/RDA-Vocabularies/blob/master/ttl/Elements/i.ttl","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDAI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/i/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Item properties element set consists of properties representing the attributes and relationships of the RDA Item entity.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"FRBR\"]","dct:title":"RDA Item properties","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Joint Steering Committee for Development of RDA\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc0b65d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc0b65d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.rda-jsc.org/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-12-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAI&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/i","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/i"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/a, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/c, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/m]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/rdakit/, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/RegAp/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/a, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/c, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/m]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gordon Dunsire\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f18135d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f18135d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2.4.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/RDA"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.75,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1068},"RDAM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/m"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/RDARegistry/RDA-Vocabularies/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDAM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/m/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Manifestation properties element set consists of properties representing the attributes and relationships of the RDA Manifestation entity.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"FRBR\"]","dct:title":"RDA Manifestation properties","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Joint Steering Committee for Development of RDA\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc0b65d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc0b65d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.rda-jsc.org/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-12-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAM&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/m","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/m"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/i, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/a, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/c, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/e, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/rdakit/, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/RegAp/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/i, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/a, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/c, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/e, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gordon Dunsire\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f18135d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f18135d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2.4.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/RDA"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.75,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":953},"RDAREL":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/RDARelationshipsWEMI"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDAREL","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdvocab.info/RDARelationshipsWEMI/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A vocabulary defining a large variety of specific relationships between the various levels of the FRBR pile.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Metadata\"]","dct:title":"RDA Relationships for Works, Expressions, Manifestations, Items","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAREL/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-03-09T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAREL&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAREL/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAREL/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAREL/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAREL&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAREL/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAREL/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAREL","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/RDARelationshipsWEMI","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/RDARelationshipsWEMI"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://example.org/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA/, http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/RegAp/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.75,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://example.org/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA/, http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAREL/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.75,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Metadata Management Associates\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf395bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf395bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://managemetadata.com/\"}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAREL/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2012-03-09"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/RDA, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/FRBR]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":240.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2722},"RDAROLE":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/roles"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://dublincore.org/dcmirdataskgroup","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDAROLE","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdvocab.info/roles/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Defines possible roles linking agents to FRBR objects (works, expressions, manifestations, items)","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"FRBR\"]","dct:title":"RDA Roles","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Metadata Management Associates\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf395bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bf395bb0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://managemetadata.com/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAROLE/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-01-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAROLE&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAROLE/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAROLE/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAROLE/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAROLE&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/de, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAROLE/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAROLE/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAROLE","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/roles","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdvocab.info/roles"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":98.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/RegAp/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":8.75,"normalizedScore":27,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://rdvocab.info/uri/schema/FRBRentitiesRDA","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAROLE/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":48.75,"normalizedScore":44,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAROLE/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-01-11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/RDA, https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/FRBR]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":241.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1601},"RDAU":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/u"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDAU","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/u/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Unconstrained properties element set consists of properties representing the attributes and relationships of the all RDA entities. Each property in the element set has semantics which are independent of the FRBR model and has no specified domain or range.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"FRBR\"]","dct:title":"RDA Unconstrained properties","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Joint Steering Committee for Development of RDA\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc0b65d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc0b65d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.rda-jsc.org/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAU/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-12-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAU&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAU/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAU/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAU/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAU&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAU/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAU/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAU","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/u","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/u"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/RegAp/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":3.75,"normalizedScore":11,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAU/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":43.75,"normalizedScore":40,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gordon Dunsire\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f18135d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f18135d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAU/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-12-30"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/RDA"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":243.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":869},"RDAW":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/RDARegistry/RDA-Vocabularies/blob/master/ttl/Elements/w.ttl","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RDAW","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Work properties element set consists of properties representing the attributes and relationships of the RDA Work entity.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"FRBR\"]","dct:title":"RDA Work properties","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Joint Steering Committee for Development of RDA\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc0b65d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/bc0b65d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://www.rda-jsc.org/\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAW/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-12-31T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAW&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAW/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAW/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAW/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RDAW&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAW/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAW/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAW","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html, text/plain], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/w"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/i, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/a, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/c, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/e, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/m]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/u\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/rdakit/, http://metadataregistry.org/uri/profile/RegAp/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/i, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/a, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/c, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/e, http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/m]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAW/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://rdaregistry.info/Elements/u\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Gordon Dunsire\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f18135d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f18135d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RDAW/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2.4.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/RDA"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.75,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":894},"RLOG":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://persistence.uni-leipzig.org/nlp2rdf/ontologies/rlog#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"https://github.com/NLP2RDF/ontologies/blob/master/rlog/rlog.ttl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":73,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RLOG","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://persistence.uni-leipzig.org/nlp2rdf/ontologies/rlog#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This is a helper ontology for NIF 2.0 to be able to log errors and warning messages.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"API\"]","dct:title":"RDF Logging Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"rlog","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RLOG/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-04-01T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RLOG&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This is a helper ontology for NIF 2.0 to be able to log errors and warning messages.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RLOG/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RLOG/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RLOG/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RLOG&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RLOG/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RLOG/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RLOG","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":74.0,"normalizedScore":65,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://persistence.uni-leipzig.org/nlp2rdf/ontologies/rlog#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://persistence.uni-leipzig.org/nlp2rdf/ontologies/rlog#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RLOG/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sebastian Hellmann\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/7c874c40-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/7c874c40-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RLOG/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":254.44,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":683},"VRA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://simile.mit.edu/2003/10/ontologies/vraCore3#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"VRA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://simile.mit.edu/2003/10/ontologies/vraCore3#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The VRA Core is a set of metadata elements to describe works of visual culture as well as the images that document them.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Image\"]","dct:title":"RDFS Ontology for VRA","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/VRA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-12-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2003-10-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=VRA&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/VRA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/VRA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2003-10-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/VRA/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=VRA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/VRA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/VRA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/VRA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://simile.mit.edu/2003/10/ontologies/vraCore3#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://simile.mit.edu/2003/10/ontologies/vraCore3#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/VRA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/VRA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2003-10-14"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":233.75,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":824},"REMETCA":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.purl.org/net/remetca#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"REMETCA","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.purl.org/net/remetca#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Ontology for poetry description","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"SPAR\"]","dct:title":"ReMetCa Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"remetca","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/REMETCA/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2014-10-14T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=REMETCA&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Version 1.1\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/REMETCA/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/REMETCA/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/REMETCA/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=REMETCA&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/REMETCA/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/REMETCA/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/REMETCA","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":65.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.purl.org/net/remetca#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.purl.org/net/remetca#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.cidoc-crm.org/html/5.0.4/cidoc-crm.html#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.13,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://creativecommons.org/ns, http://www.purl.org/dc/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.13,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.cidoc-crm.org/html/5.0.4/cidoc-crm.html#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/REMETCA/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.13,"normalizedScore":45,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Elena Gonzalez Blanco\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c897a470-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c897a470-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/REMETCA/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/groups/SPAR"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":261.13,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1512},"ROV":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/regorg"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://www.w3.org/2011/gld/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"ROV","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.w3.org/ns/regorg#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Registered Organization Vocabulary is a profile of the Organization Ontology for describing organizations that have gained legal entity status through a formal registration process, typically in a national or regional register.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Society\"]","dct:title":"Registered Organization Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"rov","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ROV/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"The Registered Organization Vocabulary is a profile of the Organization Ontology for describing organizations that have gained legal entity status through a formal registration process, typically in a national or regional register.","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2013-12-21T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ROV&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This file specifies the set of RDF classes and properties used in the Registered Organization Vocabulary vocabulary\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ROV/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ROV/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2013-05-24T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ROV/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=ROV&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ROV/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ROV/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ROV","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/regorg","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.w3.org/ns/regorg"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://purl.org/vocommons/voaf, http://www.w3.org/2007/05/powder-s]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ROV/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms\",\"http://www.w3.org/ns/org#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Andrea Perego\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cf384fd0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/cf384fd0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Phil Archer\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f3fa3250-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f3fa3250-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/ROV/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2013-12-21"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":239.44,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":460},"WAI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/wai#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://vocab.ctic.es/wai/wai.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"WAI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/wai#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"||WAI vocabulary aims to extend the FOAF specification through introducing the concepts of roles and profiles. In society, people are more than just persons, they can be musicians, presidents of government, firemen, football players or car drivers in a traffic jam.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"People\"]","dct:title":"Roles and Profiles Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/WAI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2010-10-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=WAI&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/WAI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/WAI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2010-10-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/WAI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=WAI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/WAI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/WAI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/WAI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/wai#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/wai#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/WAI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Luis Polo\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/da97aa80-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/da97aa80-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Diego Berrueta\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8cbe3220-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/8cbe3220-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Emilio Rubiera\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/acb232e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/acb232e0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":\"CTIC\",\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"CTIC Foundation\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0164e170-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0164e170-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://data.semanticweb.org/organization/fundacion-ctic\"}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/WAI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2010-10-11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":249.75,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1248},"PNI":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.press.net/ontology/identifier/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://data.press.net/ontology/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"PNI","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://data.press.net/ontology/identifier/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Identifier Ontology models non-RDF based Identifiers for resources. It  is used to maintain a mapping between RDF resources identifiers and their equivalent IDs in an alternate, non-RDF based domain.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Support\"]","dct:title":"SNaP Identifier Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PNI/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-03-21T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PNI&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The Identifier Ontology models non-RDF based Identifiers for resources. The enables us to maintain a mapping between RDF resources identifiers and their equivalent IDs in an alternate, non-RDF based domain.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PNI/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PNI/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2012-03-21T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PNI/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=PNI&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PNI/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PNI/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PNI","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.press.net/ontology/identifier/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://data.press.net/ontology/identifier/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2003/06/sw-vocab-status/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PNI/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paul Wilton\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9ac12a50-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/9ac12a50-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Paul Harman\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b0bfbb50-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b0bfbb50-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Matt Nathan\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e45c3ee0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e45c3ee0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jarred McGinnis\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f259a3d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f259a3d0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/PNI/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.3.0"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.75,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":412},"SPIN":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://spinrdf.org/spin"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://spinrdf.org/spin.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SPIN","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://spinrdf.org/spin#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An RDF Schema that can be used to attach constraints and rules to RDFS classes, and to encapsulate reusable SPARQL queries into functions and templates.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"RDF\"]","dct:title":"SPIN Inferencing Vocabulary","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SPIN/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2014-08-28T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SPIN&q=","schema:comment":"[\"An RDF Schema that can be used to attach constraints and rules to RDFS classes, and to encapsulate reusable SPARQL queries into functions and templates.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SPIN/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SPIN/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SPIN/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SPIN&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SPIN/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SPIN/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SPIN","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://spinrdf.org/spin","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://spinrdf.org/spin"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://spinrdf.org/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://spinrdf.org/sp, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://spinrdf.org/sp\"]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://spinrdf.org/sp\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://spinrdf.org/sp]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://spinrdf.org/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://spinrdf.org/sp, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SPIN/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://spinrdf.org/sp\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://spinrdf.org/sp\"]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Holger Knublauch\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f458f370-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/f458f370-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SPIN/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.3.2"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":243.75,"normalizedScore":50,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":911},"SCSV":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.deri.ie/scsv"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://vocab.deri.ie/scsv.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SCSV","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/NET/schema-org-csv#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Mapping vocabulary for CSV files that use Schema.org terms in the header.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"CSV\"]","dct:title":"Schema.org CSV","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"scsv","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCSV/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-05-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SCSV&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCSV/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCSV/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2012-05-22T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCSV/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SCSV&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCSV/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCSV/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCSV","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.deri.ie/scsv","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://vocab.deri.ie/scsv"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.5,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.5,"normalizedScore":17,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCSV/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.5,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Michael Hausenblas\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fafd3600-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/fafd3600-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCSV/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2012-05-22"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":234.5,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":6264},"SCIP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://lod.taxonconcept.org/ontology/sci_people.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SCIP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://lod.taxonconcept.org/ontology/sci_people.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A vocabulary for description of scientific people, focused on bio sciences","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Academy\"]","dct:title":"Scientific People Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"TaxonConcept Knowledge Base Project\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e8cf9300-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e8cf9300-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://lod.taxonconcept.org/ontology/txn.owl#TaxonConcept_Knowledge_Base_Project\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCIP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2012-07-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SCIP&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCIP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCIP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2012-02-08T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCIP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SCIP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCIP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCIP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCIP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://lod.taxonconcept.org/ontology/sci_people.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://lod.taxonconcept.org/ontology/sci_people.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://lod.taxonconcept.org/ontology/txn.owl, http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://lod.taxonconcept.org/ontology/txn.owl, http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/, http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCIP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/bibo/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Peter J. DeVries\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a0a7a260-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a0a7a260-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SCIP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2012-02-08"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":253.75,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":2210},"STEP":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/net/step"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"STEP","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/net/step#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A lightweight ontology for representing semantic trajectories and contextual elements in terms of features of interests and episodes.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Geography\",\"Time\"]","dct:title":"Semantic Trajectory Episodes","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"step","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/STEP/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-11-03T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=STEP&q=","schema:comment":"[\"Please cite the following paper if you use or refer to this ontology: \\n\\nT. P. Nogueira and H. Martin, \\\"Querying Semantic Trajectory Episodes\\\" in 4th ACM SIGSPATIAL International Workshop on Mobile Geographic Information Systems (MobiGIS'15), 2015.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/STEP/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/STEP/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/STEP/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=STEP&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/STEP/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/STEP/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/STEP","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":65.0,"normalizedScore":57,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/net/step","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/net/step"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.opengis.net/ont/sf, http://purl.oclc.org/NET/ssnx/qu/qu, http://www.w3.org/2006/time, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://www.opengis.net/ont/sf\",\"http://www.w3.org/2006/time\"]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.opengis.net/ont/sf, http://purl.oclc.org/NET/ssnx/qu/qu, http://www.w3.org/2006/time, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/STEP/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[\"http://www.opengis.net/ont/sf\",\"http://www.w3.org/2006/time\"]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Tales Paiva Nogueira\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/de1ab5c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/de1ab5c0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Hervé Martin\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0ad60890-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0ad60890-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/STEP/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":246.44,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1255},"SIOC":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdfs.org/sioc/ns#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://rdfs.org/sioc/spec/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SIOC","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdfs.org/sioc/ns#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://rdfs.org/sioc/spec","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"SIOC is an ontology for describing the information in online communities.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Society\"]","dct:title":"Semantically-Interlinked Online Communities","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SIOC/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2010-03-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SIOC&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SIOC/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SIOC/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SIOC/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SIOC&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SIOC/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SIOC/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SIOC","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":68.0,"normalizedScore":60,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdfs.org/sioc/ns#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdfs.org/sioc/ns#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/rdfg-1/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.75,"normalizedScore":33,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2004/03/trix/rdfg-1/, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SIOC/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.75,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SIOC/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.35"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":10,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":27.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":252.75,"normalizedScore":52,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":453},"SEQ":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/cp/owl/sequence.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SEQ","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/cp/owl/sequence.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"Intended to represent sequence schemas. It defines the notion of transitive and intransitive precedence and their inverses.  It can then be used between tasks, processes, time intervals, spatially locate objects, situations, etc.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Support\"]","dct:title":"Sequence Pattern","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SEQ/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2011-01-30T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SEQ&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SEQ/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SEQ/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SEQ/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SEQ&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"[http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en, http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/it]","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SEQ/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SEQ/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SEQ","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/cp/owl/sequence.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/cp/owl/sequence.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/cpannotationschema.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":13.75,"normalizedScore":42,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SEQ/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":53.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Valentina Presutti\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/da6109b0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/da6109b0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Aldo Gangemi\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0f70b2f0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0f70b2f0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SEQ/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":9.0,"normalizedScore":23,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":32.0,"normalizedScore":22,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":256.75,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":460},"SNARM":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdf.myexperiment.org/ontologies/snarm/"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SNARM","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdf.myexperiment.org/ontologies/snarm/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"This ontology is designed for representing access rights within a simple network of associated users/groups","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"API\"]","dct:title":"Simple Network Access Rights Management Ontology","dct:publisher":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"organization\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"myExperiment\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e6063000-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/e6063000-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":\"http://rdf.myexperiment.org\"}]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SNARM/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2011-09-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SNARM&q=","schema:comment":"[\"This ontology is designed for representing access rights within a simple network of associated users/groups.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SNARM/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SNARM/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SNARM/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SNARM&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SNARM/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SNARM/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SNARM","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":74,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":66.0,"normalizedScore":58,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdf.myexperiment.org/ontologies/snarm/","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats. (Ontology is not content-negotiable, Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdf.myexperiment.org/ontologies/snarm/"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":92.0,"normalizedScore":81,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.75,"normalizedScore":17,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SNARM/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.75,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"David R Newman\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/48cca960-d588-013d-b4bc-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/48cca960-d588-013d-b4bc-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SNARM/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v1.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":233.75,"normalizedScore":48,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":248},"SSSO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/ssso"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":12.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"https://github.com/gbv/ssso/","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SSSO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/ontology/ssso#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"An event-based RDF ontology for typical status in fulfillment of a service","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Services\"]","dct:title":"Simple Service Status Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"ssso","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SSSO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2014-07-02T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SSSO&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SSSO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SSSO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"2013-11-19T00:00:00.000+00:00","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SSSO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SSSO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SSSO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SSSO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SSSO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":77,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":67.0,"normalizedScore":59,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/ssso","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/ontology/ssso"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","properties":{"dct:relation":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1\",\"http://schema.org/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://linkedevents.org/ontology/\",\"http://www.europeana.eu/schemas/edm/\",\"http://www.semanticdesktop.org/ontologies/2007/04/02/ncal\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/c4dm/event.owl#\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/service\",\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/DUL.owl#\",\"http://purl.org/NET/cidoc-crm/core#\",\"http://purl.org/tio/ns#\",\"http://purl.org/dc/dcmitype/\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.33,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://creativecommons.org/ns]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":5.33,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SSSO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://purl.org/goodrelations/v1\",\"http://schema.org/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://linkedevents.org/ontology/\",\"http://www.europeana.eu/schemas/edm/\",\"http://www.semanticdesktop.org/ontologies/2007/04/02/ncal\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/c4dm/event.owl#\",\"http://purl.org/ontology/service\",\"http://www.loa-cnr.it/ontologies/DUL.owl#\",\"http://purl.org/NET/cidoc-crm/core#\",\"http://purl.org/tio/ns#\",\"http://purl.org/dc/dcmitype/\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":45.33,"normalizedScore":41,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":15.0,"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":26.0,"normalizedScore":70,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jakob Voß\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/268a3150-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/268a3150-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SSSO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.3"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":45.0,"normalizedScore":31,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":258.33,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":1522},"SITU":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/cp/owl/situation.owl"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"SITU","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/cp/owl/situation.owl#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"A pattern to represent contexts or situations, and the things that are contextualized.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Events\"]","dct:title":"Situation Pattern","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SITU/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2015-01-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SITU&q=","schema:comment":"[]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SITU/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SITU/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SITU/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=SITU&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SITU/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SITU/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SITU","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/cp/owl/situation.owl","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":24.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/cp/owl/situation.owl"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":37.0,"normalizedScore":86,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":107.0,"normalizedScore":94,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/cpannotationschema.owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"http://www.ontologydesignpatterns.org/schemas/","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SITU/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Valentina Presutti\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/da6109b0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/da6109b0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Aldo Gangemi\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0f70b2f0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/0f70b2f0-d4f7-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/SITU/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v2015-01-11"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":30.0,"normalizedScore":20,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":256.75,"normalizedScore":53,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":631},"RUTO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdfunit.aksw.org/ns/core#"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":14.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"http://aksw.org/Projects/RDFUnit.html","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"RUTO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://rdfunit.aksw.org/ns/core#","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"http://aksw.org/Projects/RDFUnit.html","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"The Databugger ontology describes concepts used in Databugger, a test driven data-debugging framework that can run automatically generated (based on a schema) and manually generated test cases against an endpoint.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"Quality\"]","dct:title":"Test-Driven Data Debugging Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"rut","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RUTO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2014-01-10T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RUTO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"The RDFUnit ontology describes concepts used in RDFUnit, a test driven data-debugging framework that can run automatically generated (based on a schema) and manually generated test cases against an endpoint.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RUTO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RUTO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RUTO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=RUTO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RUTO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RUTO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RUTO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":23.0,"normalizedScore":85,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":69.0,"normalizedScore":61,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdfunit.aksw.org/ns/core#","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":21.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html, application/rdf+xml], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://rdfunit.aksw.org/ns/core#"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":34.0,"normalizedScore":79,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":104.0,"normalizedScore":92,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","properties":{"owl:imports":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://persistence.uni-leipzig.org/nlp2rdf/ontologies/rlog#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://persistence.uni-leipzig.org/nlp2rdf/ontologies/rlog#\",\"http://spinrdf.org/spin\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.44,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://purl.org/dc/terms/, http://purl.org/vocab/vann/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":10.44,"normalizedScore":32,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"[http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl, http://persistence.uni-leipzig.org/nlp2rdf/ontologies/rlog#, http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema]","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RUTO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/ns/prov#\",\"http://purl.org/dc/terms/\",\"http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#\",\"http://persistence.uni-leipzig.org/nlp2rdf/ontologies/rlog#\",\"http://spinrdf.org/spin\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":50.44,"normalizedScore":46,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":8.0,"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","properties":{"dct:license":"http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":19.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about the actors involved in its development?","score":3.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","properties":{"schema:translator":"[]","dct:creator":"[{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sebastian Hellmann\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/7c874c40-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/7c874c40-da5d-013d-00ee-5254007cab39\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Patrick Westphal\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/900643f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/900643f0-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Dimitris Kontokosta\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a995a550-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/a995a550-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Jens Lehmann\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b6a2f790-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/b6a2f790-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Sören Auer\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c8222e40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/c8222e40-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null},{\"creator\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/users/admin\",\"agentType\":\"person\",\"acronym\":null,\"identifiers\":[],\"@type\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/Agent\",\"name\":\"Roland Cornelissen\",\"id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/dd18b340-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@id\":\"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/Agents/dd18b340-d4f6-013d-a223-525400a45c58\",\"@context\":{\"creator\":{\"@type\":\"@id\",\"@id\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/User\"},\"@vocab\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/\",\"agentType\":\"http://data.bioontology.org/metadata/agentType\",\"acronym\":\"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel\",\"identifiers\":\"http://www.w3.org/ns/adms#identifier\",\"@language\":\"en\",\"name\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/name\",\"email\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/mbox\",\"homepage\":\"http://xmlns.com/foaf/0.1/homepage\"},\"email\":null,\"homepage\":null}]","dct:contributor":"[]","pav:curatedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform about the actors involved in its development.","score":8.0}]},"R1.2Q2":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information on its general provenance?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","properties":{"prov:wasGeneratedBy":"[]","prov:wasInvalidatedBy":"[]","dct:source":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform on its general provenance.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform on its general provenance.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform on its general provenance.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q3":{"question":"Are the accrual methods and policy of the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","properties":{"dct:accrualPolicy":"null","dct:accrualMethod":"[]","dct:accrualPeriodicity":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 accrual property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 accrual property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 accrual properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 accrual properties.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology clearly versioned with version information and links to previous versions?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","properties":{"dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/RUTO/submissions","owl:priorVersion":"null","owl:versionInfo":"v0.4.1"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides O property to inform about versioning.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about versioning.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 or more properties to inform about versioning.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q5":{"question":"Are the ontology latest changes documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":2.0}]},"R1.2Q6":{"question":"Are the methodology and tools used to build the ontology documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","properties":{"omv:conformsToKnowledgeRepresentationParadigm":"null","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringTool":"[]","omv:usedOntologyEngineeringMethodology":"null"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about methodology and tools used.","score":6.0}]},"R1.2Q7":{"question":"Is the ontology rationale documented?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","properties":{"omv:designedForOntologyTask":"[]","mod:competencyQuestion":"[]"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about rationale documentation.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about rationale documentation.","score":4.0}]},"R1.2Q8":{"question":"Does an ontology inform about its funding organization?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","properties":{"foaf:fundedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not inform about its funding organization.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology informs about its funding organization.","score":2.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":38.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"R1.3":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata meet domain-relevant community standards.","results":{"R1.3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide information about projects using or organizations endorsing?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","properties":{"mod:ontologyInUse":"[]","omv:endorsedBy":"[]"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects or endorsing organizations.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provide information about projects and endorsing organizations.","score":10.0}]},"R1.3Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology included in a specific community set or group?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","properties":{"mod:group":"[]"},"maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not provide information about its community set or group.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in one of this groups: \"WHEAT\", \"CROP\", \"INRAE\".","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is included in the OBO library and is part of the OBO Foundry.","score":20.0}]},"R1.3Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology openly and freely available?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not openly and freely available.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is openly and freely available.","score":6.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":36.0,"portalMaxCredits":36.0},"score":38.0,"normalizedScore":26,"maxCredits":143.0,"portalMaxCredits":114.0},"score":261.44,"normalizedScore":54,"maxCredits":478.0,"executionTime":854},"BIRO":{"Findable":{"F1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are assigned a globally unique and persistent identifier. ","results":{"F1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology have a \"local\" identifier, i.e., a globally unique and potentially permanent identifier assigned by the developer (or developing organization)?","score":9.0,"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/spar/biro"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology URI is present and valid.","score":9.0}]},"F1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide an additional \"external\" identifier, i.e., a guarantee globally unique and persistent identifier assigned by an accredited body? If yes, is the external identifier a DOI?","score":0.0,"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","properties":{"dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"External identifier is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present but invalid.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is present and valid.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is an invalid DOI.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"External identifier is a valid DOI.","score":11.0}]},"F1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata clearly identified either by the same identifier than the ontology (if included in the ontology file) or with its own globally unique and persistent identifier?","score":12.0,"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","maxCredits":12.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology metadata clearly identified: the repository explicitly identifies its metadata.","score":12.0}]},"F1Q4":{"question":"Does the ontology provide a version-specific URI, and is this URI resolvable?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","properties":{"owl:versionIRI":"null"},"maxCredits":9.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Version URI is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present but invalid.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid but not resolvable.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Version URI is present, valid and resolvable.","score":9.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":41.0,"portalMaxCredits":41.0},"F2":{"label":"Ontologies are described with rich ontology metadata.","results":{"F2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO must' metadata properties? ","score":10.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","properties":{"omv:knownUsage":"[]","foaf:homepage":"null","void:uriRegexPattern":"null","omv:acronym":"BIRO","vann:preferredNamespaceUri":"http://purl.org/spar/biro/","dct:subject":"[]","dct:coverage":"null","dct:audience":"null","foaf:page":"null","doap:bugDatabase":"null","skos:hiddenLabel":"[]","idot:exampleIdentifier":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","vann:example":"[]","mod:hasEvaluation":"[]","dct:alternative":"[]","doap:mailing-list":"null","dct:description":"BiRO, the Bibliographic Reference Ontology, is an ontology structured according to the FRBR model to define bibliographic records (as subclasses of frbr:Work) and bibliographic references (as subclasses of frbr:Expression), and their compilations into bibliographic collections such as library catalogues, and into bibliographic lists such as reference lists in journal articles, respectively.","omv:resourceLocator":"null","omv:keywords":"[\"SPAR\"]","dct:title":"The Bibliographic Reference Ontology","dct:publisher":"[]","doap:repository":"null"},"maxCredits":16.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'MIRO must' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'MIRO must' property.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'MIRO must' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'MIRO must' properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'MIRO must' properties.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'MIRO must' properties.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 'MIRO must' properties.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 'MIRO must' properties.","score":14.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 8 or more 'MIRO must' properties.","score":16.0}]},"F2Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology described with additional 'MIRO should' or 'optional' metadata properties?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","properties":{"omv:numberOfClasses":"","omv:numberOfProperties":"","vann:preferredNamespacePrefix":"null","mod:metrics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BIRO/metrics","omv:numberOfAxioms":"","omv:numberOfIndividuals":""},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 'should or optional' property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 'should or optional' property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 'should or optional' properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 'should or optional' properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 or more 'should or optional' properties.","score":4.0}]},"F2Q3":{"question":"Is the ontology described with another metadata property with no explicit corresponding MIRO requirement?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","omv:isOfType":"http://omv.ontoware.org/2005/05/ontology#Vocabulary","omv:keyClasses":"[]","dct:dateSubmitted":"2025-02-25T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:abstract":"null","mod:classesWithMoreThan25Children":"","dct:created":"2013-05-11T00:00:00.000+00:00","dct:bibliographicCitation":"[]","pav:curatedOn":"[]","foaf:depiction":"[]","void:openSearchDescription":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=BIRO&q=","schema:comment":"[\"BiRO, the Bibliographic Reference Ontology is an ontology for describing bibliographic records and references, and their compilation into bibliographic collections and reference lists. It forms part of SPAR, a suite of Semantic Publishing and Referencing Ontologies.  Other SPAR ontologies are described at http://purl.org/spar/.\",\"This ontology is available at http://purl.org/spar/biro, and uses the namespace prefix biro.\"]","void:propertyPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BIRO/properties","dct:valid":"null","void:classPartition":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BIRO/classes","mod:classesWithOneChild":"","dct:modified":"null","void:dataDump":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BIRO/download","foaf:logo":"null","void:uriLookupEndpoint":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/search?ontologies=BIRO&require_exact_match=true&q=","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:classesWithNoDefinition":"","schema:associatedMedia":"[]","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","dct:language":"http://lexvo.org/id/iso639-1/en","mod:analytics":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BIRO/analytics","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","void:rootResource":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BIRO/classes/roots","mod:browsingUI":"http://lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BIRO","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","schema:award":"[]","voaf:toDoList":"[]","mod:maxChildCount":""},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 0 additionnal property.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 1 additionnal property.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 2 additionnal properties.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 3 additionnal properties.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 4 additionnal properties.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 5 additionnal properties.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 6 additionnal properties.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is described with 7 or more additionnal properties.","score":7.0}]}},"score":18.0,"normalizedScore":66,"maxCredits":27.0,"portalMaxCredits":27.0},"F3":{"label":"Ontology metadata clearly and explicitly include the identifier of the ontologies they describe.","results":{"F3Q1":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata included and maintained in the ontology file?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question ","maxCredits":21.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":21.0}]},"F3Q2":{"question":"If not, are the ontology metadata described in an external file?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology repository provides ontology metadata in an external file.","score":11.0}]},"F3Q3":{"question":"Does that external file explicitly link to the ontology and vice-versa?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No explicit link between the ontology and its metadata and vice-versa.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"One explicit link between the ontology and its metadata (but no reciprocal).","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Bidirectional links between the ontology and its metadata.","score":10.0}]}},"score":21.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":21.0,"portalMaxCredits":21.0},"F4":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are registered or indexed in a searchable resource typically an ontology repository.","results":{"F4Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple ontology 'libraries'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology library.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology library.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in  2 ontology libraries.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 or more ontology libraries.","score":6.0}]},"F4Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology registered in multiple open ontology 'repositories'?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","properties":{"schema:includedInDataCatalog":"https://lov.linkeddata.es/dataset/lov"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 0 ontology repository.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 1 ontology repository.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 2 ontology repositories.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 3 ontology repositories.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 4 ontology repositories.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"The ontology is registered in 5 or more ontology repositories.","score":10.0}]},"F4Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology libraries or repositories properly indexed by Web search engines?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":8.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":8.0}]}},"score":4.0,"normalizedScore":16,"maxCredits":24.0,"portalMaxCredits":16.0},"score":64.0,"normalizedScore":56,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":105.0},"Accessible":{"A1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are retrievable by their identifier using a standardized communication protocol.","results":{"A1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology URI and other identifiers, if exist, resolve to the ontology?","score":6.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/spar/biro","dct:identifier":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 resolvable identifier.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 resolvable identifier.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 resolvable identifiers.","score":6.0}]},"A1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology URI (if metadata is included in the ontology file) or the external metadata URI resolve to the metadata record?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides an external metadata URI which resolves to the metadata record.","score":7.0}]},"A1Q3":{"question":"Do the ontology URI and the external metadata URI (if the metadata are not included in the ontology file), support content negotiation?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats. (Ontology accept the following formats: [text/html], Ontology metadata accept the following formats: [application/json, application/xml, text/html, text/plain, application/rdf+xml])","properties":{"owl:ontologyIRI":"http://purl.org/spar/biro"},"maxCredits":24.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata do not support content negotiation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 1 negotiation format.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 2 negotiation formats.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 3 negotiation formats.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology or its metadata support 4 negotiation formats.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 5 negotiation formats.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 6 negotiation formats.","score":18.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 7 negotiation formats.","score":21.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and its metadata support 8 or more negotiation formats.","score":24.0}]},"A1Q4":{"question":"Are the ontology and its metadata accessible through another standard protocol such as SPARQL?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","properties":{"sd:endpoint":"[]"},"maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology is not accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being accessible through a SPARQL endpoint.","score":6.0}]}},"score":31.0,"normalizedScore":72,"maxCredits":43.0,"portalMaxCredits":43.0},"A1.1":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata is open, free and universally implementable.","results":{"A1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology relying on HTTP/URIs for its identification and access mechanisms?","score":20.0,"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses HTTP/URIs for identification and access mechanisms.","score":20.0}]},"A1.1Q2":{"question":"Is the ontology access protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository access protocols (HTTP/URIs) are open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]},"A1.1Q3":{"question":"If the ontology and metadata are accessible through another protocol, is that protocol open, free, and universally implementable?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository uses another protocol (SPARQL) that is open, free and universally implementable.","score":4.0}]}},"score":28.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":28.0,"portalMaxCredits":28.0},"A1.2":{"label":"The protocol to retrieve ontologies and ontology metadata supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","results":{"A1.2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible through a protocol that supports authentication and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]},"A1.2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible through a protocol that supports authentification and authorization?","score":11.0,"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","maxCredits":11.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports authentification and authorization when an ontology has access restriction.","score":11.0}]}},"score":22.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":22.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"A2":{"label":"Ontology metadata should be accessible even when the ontology is no longer available.","results":{"A2Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology accessible in a repository that supports versioning?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository supports versioning.","score":7.0}]},"A2Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata of each version available?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata for each version of the ontology.","score":5.0}]},"A2Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology metadata accessible even if no more versions of the ontology are available?","score":4.0,"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The repository provides metadata even if no more versions of the ontology are available.","score":4.0}]},"A2Q4":{"question":"Is the status of the ontology clearly informed?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","properties":{"owl:deprecated":"false","omv:status":"production"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology status absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status partially specified.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"Ontology status fully specified.","score":4.0}]}},"score":20.0,"normalizedScore":100,"maxCredits":20.0,"portalMaxCredits":20.0},"score":101.0,"normalizedScore":89,"maxCredits":113.0,"portalMaxCredits":113.0},"Interoperable":{"I1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use a formal, accessible, shared and broadly applicable language for knowledge representation.","results":{"I1Q1":{"question":"What is the representation language used for ontology and ontology metadata?","score":18.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":18.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology knowledge representation language absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in PDF.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in TXT.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in CSV.","score":9.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in XML.","score":10.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OBO.","score":11.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in RDFS.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in SKOS.","score":15.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented in OWL.","score":18.0}]},"I1Q2":{"question":"Is the representation language used a W3C Recommendation?","score":10.0,"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologyLanguage":"OWL"},"maxCredits":10.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are not represented using a W3C Recommendation.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology and ontology metadata are represented using a W3C Recommendatione.","score":10.0}]},"I1Q3":{"question":"Is the syntax of the ontology informed?","score":5.0,"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","properties":{"omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology syntax is present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q4":{"question":"Is the formality level of the ontology informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","properties":{"omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology formality level absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology formality level present.","score":5.0}]},"I1Q5":{"question":"Is the availability of other syntaxes/formats informed?","score":0.0,"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","properties":{"dct:hasFormat":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null"},"maxCredits":4.0,"points":[{"explanation":"No information is provided about the availability of the ontology in other formats.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The availability of other ontology formats is informed.","score":4.0}]}},"score":33.0,"normalizedScore":75,"maxCredits":44.0,"portalMaxCredits":44.0},"I2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata use vocabularies that follow FAIR principles.","results":{"I2Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology import other FAIR vocabularies?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/spar/, http://purl.org/]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not import other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology imports other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse terms from other FAIR vocabularies (URIs)?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"dct:relation":"http://purl.org/vocab/frbr/core"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing terms from other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q3":{"question":"If yes, does it include the minimum information for those terms?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":3.0}]},"I2Q4":{"question":"Is the ontology aligned to other FAIR vocabularies?","score":0.0,"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","properties":{"voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare being aligned to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares being aligned to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":5.0}]},"I2Q5":{"question":"If yes, are those alignments well represented and to unambiguous entities? If yes, are those alignements curated?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"I2Q6":{"question":"Does the ontology provide metadata information about relation to or influence of other FAIR vocabularies?","score":2.0,"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","properties":{"schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://purl.org/co\",\"http://purl.org/vocab/frbr/core\"]","voaf:similar":"[]","dct:isPartOf":"null"},"maxCredits":2.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare influential relations to other vocabularies.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares influential relations to other vocabularies (independently of their level of FAIRness).","score":2.0}]},"I2Q7":{"question":"Does the ontology reuse standard and FAIR metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata?","score":3.75,"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","properties":{"voaf:metadataVoc":"[http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/, http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#, http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#, http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl]"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not declare reusing standards metadata vocabularies to describe its metadata.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology declares reusing standards metadata vocabularies (more or less 'FAIR') to describe its metadata.","score":5.0}]}},"score":15.75,"normalizedScore":49,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":22.0},"I3":{"label":"Ontologies or ontology metadata include qualified references to other (meta)data. ","results":{"I3Q1":{"question":"Does an ontology provide qualified cross-references to external resources/databases?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":20.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":20.0}]},"I3Q2":{"question":"If yes, are those cross-references well represented and to unambiguous entities?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"I3Q3":{"question":"Does the ontology use valid URIs to encode some metadata values?","score":7.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","properties":{"dct:hasPart":"[]","owl:imports":"[http://purl.org/spar/, http://purl.org/]","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel","omv:hasOntologySyntax":"https://www.w3.org/ns/formats/data/N3","dct:isPartOf":"null","door:comesFromTheSameDomain":"[]","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","dct:relation":"http://purl.org/vocab/frbr/core","dct:hasVersion":"https://data.lovportal.lirmm.fr/ontologies/BIRO/submissions","voaf:specializes":"[\"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl\",\"http://purl.org/co\",\"http://purl.org/vocab/frbr/core\"]","schema:translationOfWork":"[]","voaf:generalizes":"[]","door:hasDisparateModelling":"[]","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","owl:priorVersion":"null","dct:subject":"[]","dct:isFormatOf":"null","schema:workTranslation":"[]","voaf:usedBy":"[]","omv:hasFormalityLevel":"null","dct:license":"null","owl:backwardCompatibleWith":"[]","mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","voaf:hasEquivalencesWith":"[]","owl:incompatibleWith":"[]","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","dct:hasFormat":"[]","voaf:hasDisjunctionsWith":"[]","voaf:similar":"[]"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology does not use URIs to encode metadata values.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 1 metadata value encoded as URI.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 2 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 3 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 4 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 5 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":5.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 6 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":6.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides at least 7 metadata values encoded as URIs.","score":7.0}]}},"score":7.0,"normalizedScore":21,"maxCredits":33.0,"portalMaxCredits":7.0},"score":55.75,"normalizedScore":51,"maxCredits":109.0,"portalMaxCredits":73.0},"Reusable":{"R1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes.","results":{"R1Q1":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about how classes or concepts are defined?","score":5.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","properties":{"mod:definitionProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#definition","mod:prefLabelProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#prefLabel","mod:authorProperty":"http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/creator","mod:obsoleteProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#deprecated","mod:synonymProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2004/02/skos/core#altLabel"},"maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":3.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 4 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 5 properties to inform how classes or concepts are defined.","score":5.0}]},"R1Q2":{"question":"Does the ontology provide information about its hierarchy?","score":1.0,"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","properties":{"mod:obsoleteParent":"null","mod:hierarchyProperty":"http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#subClassOf","mod:maxDepth":""},"maxCredits":3.0,"points":[{"explanation":"The ontology provides 0 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 1 property to inform about its hierarchy.","score":1.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 2 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":2.0},{"explanation":"The ontology provides 3 properties to inform about its hierarchy.","score":3.0}]},"R1Q3":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are described with labels?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":7.0}]},"R1Q4":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects are defined using a text description?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q5":{"question":"How much ontology objects are defined using a property restriction or an equivalent class?","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":6.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":6.0}]},"R1Q6":{"question":"How much of the ontology objects provide provenance information with annotation properties? ","score":0.0,"explanation":"This question cannot be evaluated in the repository at this time.","maxCredits":5.0,"points":[{"explanation":"","score":5.0}]}},"score":6.0,"normalizedScore":18,"maxCredits":32.0,"portalMaxCredits":5.0},"R1.1":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are released with a clear and accessible usage license.","results":{"R1.1Q1":{"question":"Is the ontology license clearly specified, with an URI that is resolvable and supports content negotiation?","score":0.0,"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","properties":{"dct:license":"null"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology license absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present but not a valid URI.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present and valid but not resolvable.","score":8.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license present, valid, resolvable but with no content negotiation.","score":12.0},{"explanation":"Ontology license is clearly specified with a valid and resolvable URI that supports content negotiation.","score":15.0}]},"R1.1Q2":{"question":"Are the ontology access rights specified and permissions documented?","score":4.0,"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","properties":{"dct:accessRights":"public","cc:morePermissions":"null"},"maxCredits":7.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology access rights and permissions absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified.","score":4.0},{"explanation":"Ontology access rights are clearly specified and permissions are documented.","score":7.0}]},"R1.1Q3":{"question":"Are the ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder documented?","score":7.0,"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","properties":{"cc:useGuidelines":"null","dct:rightsHolder":"admin"},"maxCredits":15.0,"points":[{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are absent.","score":0.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines or copyright holder is absent.","score":7.0},{"explanation":"Ontology usage guidelines and copyright holder are present.","score":15.0}]}},"score":11.0,"normalizedScore":29,"maxCredits":37.0,"portalMaxCredits":37.0},"R1.2":{"label":"Ontologies and ontology metadata are associated with detailed provenance.","results":{"R1.2Q1":{"q